Articles Written 2
Article Views 646

Joyce Harman

Achievements

About Joyce Harman

Latest Articles Written

Understanding Lyme Disease, Part II: The Diagnosis

Dr. Joyce Harman presents a four-part series to help horse owners better understand the increasingly-common but often misunderstood Lyme disease.

In Part I of this series, you learned that Lyme disease is caused by a specific type of bacteria called a spirochete, and it is able to disguise itself to sneak into mammal immune systems undetected. You also learned about the symptoms of Lyme disease. Here, we’ll talk about how to properly diagnose the illness.

Diagnosis

A combination of a thorough history along with a complete physical exam and blood work are required. The history often becomes the most important aspect. Many if not most affected horses show behavioral changes of various sorts, the most usual being lethargy, irritability or lack of interest in their surroundings. In some cases, the behavioral changes are more towards the hyperactive or spooky side. The key is that there has been a significant mental change.

The physical part of the history can include shifting leg lameness, stiffness, poor performance, and reluctance to turn, poor jumping performance etc. In many cases, horses have been worked up for subtle lameness and have had traditional treatments such as joint injections and various anti-inflammatories, but have not responded well. Diagnostic imaging may be inconclusive, or may point to joint inflammation yet treatment of that inflammation yields poor results.

Laboratory diagnosis

Laboratory diagnosis of Lyme disease can be very difficult even in humans where testing is significantly more sophisticated. This is in part due to the cleverness and changeability of the spirochete. Currently the best test is the Cornell Multiplex Lyme test that gives several results, whether the infection is acute or chronic in nature. The other test that is commonly used is a SNAP test, done by your vet. This may give an idea of whether an animal is positive or negative, but does not give the detail of the Cornell test, and seems to have more false negatives.

Holistic diagnosis

Since Lyme disease has many manifestations, there is not one clear-cut pattern from a holistic perspective. From a homeopathic perspective one needs to take a complete history and prescribe a constitutional remedy based on the animal’s presentation.

From a Chinese perspective, the Liver meridian is the most affected directly and indirectly by the spirochete. Many horses will exhibit signs of Liver meridian dysfunction, however there is seldom one pattern for all horses. Wind invasion is common and many symptoms are related to that, with shifting signs. There may be Liver Qi Stagnation, Liver Heat rising, Liver Yin deficiency, Liver Blood deficiency and so on. These may be combined with other patterns, often made more complex by long-term drug use.

The real key is to approach each case as an individual, from your perspective and experience, and treat that which is in front of you. It may change from month to month as well as from year-to-year.

Stay tuned for Part III; we’ll discuss several different treatment alternatives.

About Joyce Harman: Dr. Joyce Harman opened Harmany Equine Clinic, Ltd in 1990, bringing holistic healing to horses from all walks of life, backyard retirees to Olympic competitors. Over the years, Dr. Joyce Harman has observed and adapted to the changing needs the industry. Twenty-plus years ago, no one had heard of Lyme disease or Insulin Resistance, yet today that makes up a large part of her clinical practice.

In 2001, she wrote the first paper in a peer-reviewed journal about the possibility that horses have insulin resistance (IR), and now it is part of our every day conversation. In 2004 she published the first comprehensive book on English saddle fitting since the 1800’s, with the western version of the book following in 2006. To this date, these books are the only books written by an author who is independent from a saddle company, which brings unbiased information to the horse world.

In 2015, Dr. Harman released the Harmany Muzzle, a customizable and breathable grazing muzzle designed with the horse in mind. Because she deals extensively with metabolic and insulin resistant horses, she felt it was her duty to offer them a comfortable muzzle option.

Understanding Equine Lyme Disease, Part I: What Is Lyme Disease?

Dr. Joyce Harman presents a four-part series to help horse owners better understand the increasingly-common but often misunderstood Lyme disease. In Part I, she introduces us to the basics.

Photo: Flickr/Cristian Iohan Ştefănescu/CC Photo: Flickr/Cristian Iohan Ştefănescu/CC

Lyme disease is really becoming a household name, especially for those who live on the east coast. Not only are we humans effected, but so are our dogs and pets!

Lyme disease (LD) has been recognized for about 40 or 50 years. It is now the most commonly reported tick-borne illness in the US and Europe, and is also found in Asia. The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) reports that there have been 20,000 to 30,000 confirmed human cases each year since 2002.

The actual numbers are likely much higher as many cases go unreported. Ninety-six percent of those cases are concentrated in about 15 states, mostly on the east coast from Virginia north. However, it can be found almost everywhere, so have your vet consider Lyme as part of any rule-out list.

Many people don’t realize that Lyme disease is actually a sophisticated form of bacteria called a spirochete that is carried only by certain species of ticks, predominately deer ticks (ixodes ricinus) on the East Coast with other species used in other parts of the United States and world.

Contrary to popular belief, deer are far from the only host for the infected tick, as the different tick species prefer different hosts. Many small mammals are part of the host cycle, from the white-footed mouse (the main species in the northeast) to the chipmunk, hedgehog and rat along with humans and dogs. The nymph stage ticks are the source of most infections while the adult tick, which is a little larger and easier to see, may be less important.

Typically, horse and human bodies mount a quick response when a foreign bacterium enters the bloodstream. However, when infected ticks are feeding, the crafty spirochete coats itself with a protein before entering the body, thereby flying under the immune system’s radar.

The spirochetes can then change themselves in a variety of ways so the immune system does not have one single threat to respond to. The spirochete cells also communicate between themselves and exchange information to evade antibiotics, an event that also occurs with other resistant bacteria.

While in the body, the spirochetes continue to alter their structure from moment to moment. This probably contributes to the various symptoms that are part of the Lyme picture, as well as the resistance to treatment.

Spirochetes are attracted to different kinds of cells in the hosts, particularly collagen, so joints, aqueous humor of the eye, meninges of the brain, skin collagen and heart tissue (less so in the equine for an unknown reason) are all susceptible.

The longer the spirochetes are in the body prior to treatment, the more adjusted they become to the specific immune situation in that host. An example of how this works is that the spirochetes may stay in the synovial lining of a joint, then evade the immune system or the antibiotic by entering the synovial cells. Once the antibiotics are out of the system or the immune system is weakened, the spirochetes reenter the joint.

What’s interesting is that the quantity of spirochetes seem to have little to no impact on the severity of the disease.

Symptoms

The characteristic bull’s-eye skin lesion is generally missing in the equine, most likely due to their hair coat. One of the most common things we do see is lameness that is difficult to specifically identify. In humans, cognitive problems, irritability, fatigue, headaches, disorganization, nerve pain, deficits in memory and retrieval of information, perceptual motor skills and problem solving are all serious issues. All of these likely exist in the horse, though usually what we see is irritability, fatigue, lack of interest in work, perhaps a stubbornness or perceived stubbornness, or dullness, all of which are difficult to diagnose.

Arthritis attacks may be periodic and may wax and wane. The waxing and waning of the symptoms may have to do with the ability of the immune system to respond. Studies have shown that the primary factor leading to arthritic inflammation is the health of the immune system.

Stay tuned for Part II, in which we’ll discuss diagnosis.

About Joyce Harman: Dr. Joyce Harman opened Harmany Equine Clinic, Ltd in 1990, bringing holistic healing to horses from all walks of life, backyard retirees to Olympic competitors. Over the years, Dr. Joyce Harman has observed and adapted to the changing needs the industry. Twenty-plus years ago, no one had heard of Lyme disease or Insulin Resistance, yet today that makes up a large part of her clinical practice.

In 2001, she wrote the first paper in a peer-reviewed journal about the possibility that horses have insulin resistance (IR), and now it is part of our every day conversation. In 2004 she published the first comprehensive book on English saddle fitting since the 1800’s, with the western version of the book following in 2006. To this date, these books are the only books written by an author who is independent from a saddle company, which brings unbiased information to the horse world.

In 2015, Dr. Harman released the Harmany Muzzle, a customizable and breathable grazing muzzle designed with the horse in mind. Because she deals extensively with metabolic and insulin resistant horses, she felt it was her duty to offer them a comfortable muzzle option.