VIDEO: Pat Parelli and Catwalk controversy at Express Eventing

Of all the things that could have gone wrong at the Express Eventing Festival of the Horse in England last weekend, I didn’t think I would be writing about a Parelli demonstration.  The Horse and Country website is reporting that a Parelli exposition didn’t work out very well:

“A demonstration by Pat Parelli caused upset when Robert Whitaker’s showjumping stallion Catwalk was worked on for two hours in front of a confused and upset audience. The stallion, who is renowned for being very difficult to bridle appeared to become upset during the demonstration. Some onlookers left the arena in difiance to Pat Parelli’s methods as the horse tried to run back to the collecting ring.”  Link: Full H&C article



The Parelli blog responded to the situation with a post titled “challenging horse lived up to its billing”:


“We ran 45 minutes over and a couple of folks were upset at what they think they saw, saying they may post on YouTube. We all have nothing to worry about except misunderstanding. Pat stopped at an appropriate time in the training process when he saw a breakthrough and preserved Catwalk’s dignity, which is more important than getting the bridle on tonight.”  Link: Parelli Blog

The Horse and Hound, which is of course the second best place for UK news behind lec, didn’t mention the incident in their Express Eventing report, but the Horse and Hound’s Forum does have a lengthy discussion that includes this reportedly first-hand account from ‘elsbells’:


“It started well and Pat continued his talk as he led the stallion around the areana on a long rope. He talked of relationships, perceptions and of course the principles of love, language and leadership. Then he pulled it’s head down as his is the Parrelli thing I guess? He then tried to touch Catwalks head and ears unsuccessfuly I might add and so became a little more forceful in his approach and asked to be brought in a saddle pad which he then slid up and down a distrssed Catwalks neck and over his face. This went on for a while and then he asked for music. The room went silent, all viewers went dumb as they watched him use a gum line as a twitch and a 22ft rope wrapped around the fetlock to the knee to haul Catwalks leg off the floor to render him unable to move while he tried to force the bride onto a now very distressed and frightened horses face!!

Catwalk hopped away and went down on his remaining knee and backed into the jump and the fence rails. Linda who’d had her face in hr hands up to this point, then raced around from her chair at the side of the areana and joined him in the fight, pulling at the rope while Pat continued to force on the bridle. The distressed horse managed to break away momentairily and run for the exit and safety. They caught him and started the whole process again where the horse stood.

I have to confess that at this point, we were unable to watch any more and had to walk out.”  

The Parellis obviously understand the importance of getting ahead of a story, and posted this heavily edited video on their Youtube account.  

Of course, what everyone is waiting for to truly understand the situation is the unedited video, and the best I have found online are these cell phone clips–view all the clips at Themetalfreehorse’s Youtube page, and here is a montage of them:
While I am certainly disturbed by the ‘elsbells’ first-hand account that the video seems to at least partially substantiate, it is important to not pass judgement on an entire program based on one misguided incident, and certainly not an entire school of thought.  Whenever things like this happen, a good part of me is disturbed by the fact that people don’t consider that this is 2010 and everyone everywhere is a walking video camera with direct upload to Youtube.

0 0 votes
Article Rating
Subscribe
Notify of
0 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments