Last week’s coverage of Pau on EN is brought to you with the support of Kentucky Performance Products. We couldn’t do much of what we’ve done these last few years without the support of sponsors such as KPP — which, by the way, is a horses-first, women owned and operated company based in, you guessed it, Kentucky — and without you, our readers! So as we head into this final hurrah of our season, too, we thank each and every one of you.
We couldn’t exactly let the final five-star of 2022 go by without our favourite game of all, could we? For this week’s edition of Who Jumped It Best, we journey back to Les 5 Etoiles de Pau in the south-west of France and, more specifically, to the second water complex, which ended up being one of the most influential sections of the course. It featured an A and a B element, and it was the B element — a yellow MIM-clipped open corner on a right-handed four-stride turn — that ended up being a particularly busy segment of this year’s track, as the clip was activated nine times throughout the day, including by the first-phase leaders, Felix Vogg and Colero.
But our focus today goes to the A element instead, which was a beefy hanging log drop on a wide right-handed turn. Riders needed to land tidily to catch the reasonably tight four strides to the B element, and they needed to get it very right, or risk that clip being activated. Have a look at each effort and then scroll down to cast your vote on who you think made the best job of it.
Hector Payne and Dynasty (GBR). Photo by Tilly Berendt.
Fiona Kashel and WSF Carthago (GBR). Photo by Tilly Berendt.
Emily King and Valmy Biats (GBR). Photo by Tilly Berendt.
David Doel and Galileo Nieuwmoed (GBR). Photo by Tilly Berendt.
Anna-Katharina Vogel and DSP Quintana P (GER). Photo by Tilly Berendt.
Alex Donohoe and Guidam Roller (IRE). Photo by Tilly Berendt.
Karim Laghouag and Triton Fontaine (FRA). Photo by Tilly Berendt.
We’re sad to report that Oslo, the Pau-winning French-bred ride of William Fox-Pitt, has died at the age of 20 after a busy, happy retirement, leaving behind a multifaceted legacy in the sport of eventing.
The Selle Français gelding (Lando x Aurelie du Prieure, by Hadj A X) was bred at Ferme de Biats France, which has made headlines at Pau again last week for the success of Emily King’s mount Valmy Biats, who was also bred by Ferme de Biats’s Philippe Brivois. Though Brivois has bred a number of top-level eventing horses, including Kitty King’s excellent Vendredi Biats and Tom Crisp’s Vendome Biats, it was Oslo who would be his first foray into breeding for this discipline, and the lynchpin of a sea change that has had a huge impact on the sport.
“When I sold Oslo Biats when he was two years old and they told me it was to do eventing, I immediately replied that it was out of the question because I didn’t want hurt my horse,” says Brivois in an interview with French magazine l’Eperon. “I bred show horses and only used champion stallions in this discipline. It was Jean-Luc Dufour who convinced me to take a full interest by explaining to me that eventing is no longer what it was. In the end, I did well to embark on this adventure.”
Oslo was best known for winning the CCI5* at Les Etoiles de Pau in 2011 as a nine-year-old, on his debut at the level, but his sixteen-run international record featured a number of highlights, with five total FEI victories and a further four top-three finishes to his name. He became the Six-Year-Old World Champion at Le Lion d’Angers in 2008 and followed that victory up with a silver at the Seven-Year-Old World Championships the following year, and in 2011, he won both the CCI4*-L at Tattersalls and the Blenheim Eight- and Nine-Year-Old CCI4*-S before tackling that fateful Pau.
William Fox-Pitt and Oslo at Badminton in 2013.
He was officially retired from competition in mid-2017 at the age of fifteen, after a spate of niggling injuries and setbacks, which included a foreleg suspensory injury that had knocked him out of contention for the 2012 London Olympics and some hock issues, which had crept in in the year of his retirement. After an initial period of downtime, in which he enjoyed time out in the field with two of his stablemates, he re-entered light work, first as a happy hacker, and then was given to William’s goddaughter, Daisy Dollar, who gained experience at BE100 (US Training) and stepped up to Novice (Preliminary) with the gelding in 2018, enjoying a competitive season of Novice classes in 2019 before Oslo’s official retirement. Since then, he’s enjoyed a relaxed life with Spencer Sturmey, partner Freddie Ellams, and Lucinda de Mauley, and was finally laid to rest in mid-October.
William Fox-Pitt and Oslo.
Oslo’s impact on the industry stretched further than his own excellent competitive record: he was also one of the first horses to be piloted under a successful syndicate, bringing the concept in from the world of racing, in which William’s wife Alice has such a wealth of experience. Though he was cut at five, he also has a significant breeding legacy: one of the sixty straws of semen taken at West Kington Stud was used to produce William’s current five-star mount, Oratorio II.
William Fox-Pitt and Oratorio II at Kentucky. Photo by Shelby Allen.
All of us at EN send our sympathies and condolences to William, Alice, Philippe, and all those connected with the horse through his extensive syndicated family.
Pinch, punch — it’s the first of the month! I used to really dread November, because for me, it always meant dragging myself home from Pau and facing many months without events. It bummed me out so much, but these days, I actually really look forward to it. A little bit of nesting; some cozy evenings in; the chance to assess the season and make plans for the next; time to read, and watch, and learn, and hone all those skills we don’t really get a chance to develop when we’re all rushing around from competition to competition. I love using these first couple of days to really unwind and write down a list of achievable goals for the next six months, whether that’s things I want to work on with my horse, ways I want to improve my house, or personal skills I’m keen to develop. Having that list in front of me definitely makes the short days feel a bit less gloomy. I’d love to know what your off-season goals are!
The first recipients of training and funding from British Eventing’s exciting new Howden Way initiative have been announced. Ten young horses, with riders ranging from established upper-level competitors to up-and-coming stars, will take part in the Young Horse Academy programme from January, with the longer-term aim of developing talent within the country. [Meet the lucky recruits]
In Piggy March’s latest column for Horse&Hound, she reflects on a couple of exciting weeks in France. From the trials and tribulations of travelling abroad post-Brexit to Le Lion’s somewhat uneven standard of judging, there’s a lot of ground covered — and as always, her sage wisdom and frankness make for fascinating reading. [To be fair, if she wrote shampoo bottle blurbs, we’d read them]
USEA member Carole Bennett just enjoyed her first horse trials at the age of 68, after decades working in Hollywood. In true eventer fashion, she reckons the thrill of the cross-country course beats any buzz at a film premier — and we’d be inclined to agree! [Read all about her first competition here]
Have you ever had one of those bright ideas that’s made you think, ‘if someone made this, it’d make them millions?’ I’m personally still waiting for someone to get on self-mucking stables, but entrepreneurs Allison Malefant and Connie DeMaio have been a bit more forward-thinking after realising that equestrians had nothing available for them that served as a comfortable, functional coverall for cold winter days. Now, there’s no stopping them. [Horse people need to be warm too]
The Ocala Horse Properties Dream Farm of the Week:
Okay, you know how I was saying I’d like to hunker down and tick some goals off my list this winter? First goal: secure this place. Second: use it to make myself the very best rider I can be. With 10 stalls, a stunning irrigated arena, plenty of acreage, close proximity to WEC, and a house that is, frankly, to die for, it’s getting my daydream machine working overtime.
Watch This:
Charisma remains one of my great celeb loves of all time, so to get us all moving on this, the first of the truly cold months, I reckon we could use a bit of inspiration from the tiny man himself.
And just like that, my 2022 competition reporting season is over! I’m a little blue, and a little overtired, this morning in the south of France, but also so excited for the off-season and all that comes with it: visiting horse sales, working on longer pieces with horsepeople I admire, and also, maybe, taking some time to work on a few projects that aren’t at all horsey to clear my cluttered brain box out. The more I chat to riders, grooms, owners, and journalists alike, the more I realise that sometimes, the smartest thing we can all do is give ourselves the leeway to step away from horses temporarily, even if just for a day or two, and feel absolutely no guilt about it. It keeps us all fresh to do so, at the end of the day, and then we can bring our best selves back to the equation when we’re ready. So for the next day and a half, it’s ciao from me as I head off road-tripping around the south of France in search of good wine, even better bread, and a bookshop or two. A demain!
National Holiday: It’s Halloween! Start it right with my favourite topical song, AFI’s cover of the Misfits classic banger. The perfect mood-setter for spooky szn.
US Weekend Action:
FEH & YEH Last Chance Qualifier & West Coast Championships (Paso Robles, CA): [Website] [Results]
Full Moon Farms H.T. (Finksburg, MD): [Website] [Results]
Your Monday Reading List:
Have you got a wobbly sense of self because you don’t really feel like you can identify as an eventer? I get that: I haven’t evented all year while my horse has some time off, but deep down, I still think of myself as one. Writer Laura Reiman muses on who gets to consider themselves a member of each discipline — and whether it even matters. [You’re an eventer if you feel like one, friends]
Honestly, if I had my way, I’d schedule a costumed class at every show. Enjoy this round-up of photos from the Washington International Horse Show, where basically everyone inexplicably showed up as Tom Cruise. [It’s better than a Peaky Blinders outfit, I guess]
I’m always impressed by people who balance riding with some other very intensive pastime — such as ultramarathons. I say this as someone who can maybe run 5km at a push, so I’m hardly likely to get inspired to take up long-distance running myself, but it’s always fascinating to see those folks who chase a multitude of dreams, and find out what makes them tick. This ‘Day in the Life’ feature Grand Prix rider and ultramarathon runner Cyndi Jackson makes for a great read. [Rather her than me, though]
Straightness is the key to basically everything you do on board your horse. Without it, he can’t truly sit on his hindend and move seamlessly between dressage movements, nor can he meet jumps in a tidy, balanced manner, so a crooked horse is far more likely to have rails down or run-outs. Here’s why it matters, and how to begin addressing the issue if you’re dealing with a bit of wonkiness. [On the straight and narrow]
You definitely want to give Belgian rider Tine Magnus your time today — not just because she won the CCI4*-S at Kronenberg yesterday, but because she’s consistently producing some of the most exciting horses on the circuit, while still flying largely under the radar. Start cheering her on now, and you’ll be able to brag that you were following her before she was famous. She certainly will be.
Morning Viewing:
Our sport is a constantly evolving one, and in the latest episode of her XC Academy series, Lucinda Green takes a closer look at how the pivotal phase has changed over the years.
This week’s coverage of Pau on EN is brought to you with the support of Kentucky Performance Products. We couldn’t do much of what we’ve done these last few years without the support of sponsors such as KPP — which, by the way, is a horses-first, women owned and operated company based in, you guessed it, Kentucky — and without you, our readers! So as we head into this final hurrah of our season, too, we thank each and every one of you.
Jonelle Price and Grappa Nera add another sterling accolade to the Price family’s roster. Photo by Tilly Berendt.
“We’ve got the his and hers versions for the mantelpiece now,” jokes Jonelle Price, who followed up husband Tim’s victory at Pau last year with one of her own today, riding The Grape Syndicate’s eleven-year-old mare, Grappa Nera (Karandasj x Cetonette, by Babalouba).
The victory came after a typically tough day in the office for many in Pau’s pivotal final phase, which boasts the lowest clear rate of the five-stars at just 17%, on average. Today’s was significantly lower than that: just three competitors delivered double-clear rounds, giving a clear rate of less than 9%, though a further five would manage clear rounds with jumping penalties.
Yann Royant’s track is difficult for a number of reasons: it’s achingly big; it’s situated on a slightly undulating surface that doesn’t have any spring to it at all, really; it makes use of technical, difficult changes in stride length; and, pivotally, it’s surrounded at close quarters on all sides by approximately the entire population of south-west France, and we’re pretty sure they’re all at least a little drunk. Every rider who enters the ring does so to colossal cheers and an intimidatingly close atmosphere, and lord help the poor souls who have to follow a clear – never mind a clear executed by a French rider.
For some horses, though, that sense of immediacy seems to lift them over the fences, which was certainly the case for diminutive, feisty Grappa Nera. She entered the ring as the penultimate competitor, having climbed from first-phase 13th to second off the back of a clear round with just 1.2 time penalties yesterday – and today, her trips to the Spanish Sunshine Tour to showjump in the off-season paid off. She delivered the third clear inside the time of the day, and all that was left to do was wait: wait for second place, perhaps, at worst, or wait to see if something rather bigger might be about to come.
Jonelle Price and Grappa Nera. Photo by Tilly Berendt.
It was. We’ve seldom seen a rider so well-supported by his fellow competitors as overnight leader David Doel, who sat on the cusp of his first-ever five-star victory with Galileo Nieuwmoed and was quietly willed over every fence by each rider along the fence line. And his excellent round — jump after jump after jump of solid distances and committed approaches — started to feel like a sure thing when he touched down from the final line and headed to the last, an airy upright on a dogleg turn. Horse and rider met it right at the distance they’d meant to, took off and, just as the crowd broke into a great roar of appreciation, gently tapped it out. Jonelle Price had become the Pau champion, one year after her husband had taken it — and just two weeks after he’d won another five-star at Maryland.
“I actually couldn’t see the last fence from where I was standing, and I just thought he jumped a clear round, so I was more looking at the clock to see if he tipped over on a time fault or two, knowing that it was so close,” she says. “Naturally, you’d be lying if you didn’t say your first reaction is jubilation. But then secondly, you feel for your fellow competitor. But I was 38 when I won my first five-star and he’s only 29 now, so he’s definitely got a few years on me — his day will come, for sure.”
For now, though, the moment — or perhaps the season — belongs to the Prices, who have been pretty well unstoppable from the word go in 2022.
“It’s quite hard to keep up with my husband at the moment,” laughs Jonelle, who was recently named World Number Two, while Tim holds World Number One status. “He’s been on fire this autumn, so I’m just trying to keep up my side of the household, really.”
Jonelle Price and Grappa Nera. Photo by Tilly Berendt.
But although the Prices are arguably eventing’s First Family, Jonelle confesses that even she had struggled with the tiniest seeds of doubt, having not taken a win at this level since Luhmühlen in 2018, which she won aboard Faerie Dianimo.
“A five-star win is always very special. I won my first two back to back in 2018, and it’s been a fairly long drought since,” she says. “I was sort of starting to wonder if I was ever going to win another one!”
In just her second-ever five-star, though, young Grape managed it — and in fine style that showed a huge progression from her debut at Kentucky last year, where she finished 8th after a mid-30s dressage score, a handful of time penalties across the country, and two rails down.
“The mare really came through for me this week; she delivered three really good phases,” says Jonelle, who took the ride over from British competitor Alex Postolowsky, who had piloted her to a win in the 2016 British Five-Year-Old Championships, in late 2017. But for all the mare’s talent, it hasn’t been an easy road to the top — and those around her have had to exercise extraordinary patience en route.
“It’s been sort of six years in the making — these things don’t happen by chance, so I’m just delighted for her. She’s got a lovely syndicate of owners who’ve been incredibly patient, and there’s been a lot of disappointments along the way but she really came through this week.”
Jonelle Price and Grappa Nera. Photo by Tilly Berendt.
Those disappointments have included rails, previously, but more pertinently, she’s been an extraordinarily mercurial horse on the flat, often flitting between the mid-20s and the high-40s to low-50s from competition to competition.
“For years I’ve been saying, ‘don’t you worry, we’ll get there!’ as she’s been cavorting around dressage arenas and whatnot at one-day events, so [the Grape Syndicate have] had to be very patient. But I always said we’d get there,” says Jonelle.
This year alone, she posted a 51.4 in the Open Intermediate at Burgham Horse Trials in July, and two weeks later, earned a 31.4 in the CCI4*-S at Haras du Pin. Last year, she twice stepped into the 40s at national Intermediate and Advanced classes; in 2019, she put a 40.3 on the board in the CCI4*-L at Millstreet. For Jonelle, the greatest investment of time has been into her mind — a bit of measured patience that has ultimately been more important, even, than the near-year the mare had off from mid-2021 to the start of this summer while rehabilitating from an injury.
All that meant, though, that while Jonelle was certain she was sitting on a horse who would be worth the wait, she wasn’t necessarily convinced that her day would come today.
“She jumped her socks off today. I always thought she was a good horse, and it was more question of when she would come through for us, not if — and she did today. But I certainly didn’t expect this — she’s a good jumper, but sometimes I think the moment can sort of get to her,” she says. That ‘moment’ was compounded by the sheer chaos of following a Frenchman who’d gone clear: “She’s quite excitable, and I knew Karim was jumping clear, so I tried to stay down the chute and just keep her a bit quiet.”
Though the mare’s stamp — she’s a petite, fine black mare — yields easy comparisons to Classic Moet, Jonelle explains that she’s not at all similar to ride and work with.
“She’s very different — if anything, I’d compare more to Faerie Dianimo. They rival each other, in terms of hotness, and because they’re both fiercely determined and athletic. And it’s delightful when they start to come of age, for sure.”
Karim Laghouag wraps up a tricky year with a bit of ‘revenge’ with Triton Fontaine. Photo by Tilly Berendt.
France’s Karim Laghouag and his Tokyo partner, Triton Fontaine, were such popular runners-up that they must have felt as though they’d won the whole thing — and, Karim ruefully recognises, they nearly could have if he hadn’t had a mistake in one of his flying changes in his dressage test.
“If I had gotten my change in time, I might have a little less to regret, but overall, it’s ok — I’m always happy to come second when it’s Jonelle who wins,” he says with a grin.
There’s more to celebrate than there is to regret, anyway: he and Triton Fontaine began their week in nineteenth place on 31.4, climbed sixteen places with one of the four clears inside the time yesterday, and then finished second overall today after stopping the clock just one second over the tight time in the showjumping ring, not only giving them a week to remember, but also putting the cap on a tricky year that’s seen Karim pick up cross-country penalties in five of his twelve total FEI runs.
“I’ve not had a great year and I really saw this competition as a good chance to come back and be with the best, even though we thought the horse was a little bit below the competition level,” says Karim, who has finished first and second at CCI4*-S this year with the 15-year-old gelding, but has also picked up penalties and retired in three internationals with him since finishing 12th individually at Tokyo.
“I had some setbacks in the beginning of the season — I was failing a lot of courses, but at least this is a nice revenge on the season, and at an event I really enjoy being at.”
Coming back to Pau also gave him the chance to bolster his own confidence by surrounding himself by the fans who love him — and their support, he points out, is crucial to the sport. What makes Pau a particularly worthy event, he continues, is that it’s all about them.
“It’s really a nice edition — although inevitably, when we do well as riders, we think it’s great,” says Karim with a laugh. “It’s becoming more and more equal with the quality of Badminton and Burghley, even if we don’t have the hills. It’s really an incredible event with the public, and it’s really important for the sport to have the public and for us to have [organiser] Pascal, who takes care of the public who are often present. For me, I think it’s very very important for the sport.”
Hector Payne and Dynasty. Photo by Tilly Berendt.
“I decided that if you’re going to do well in two phases, you might as well get it all right on the same weekend — I’m normally the king of screwing up one phase,” laughs Hector Payne, who added just 0.4 time penalties to leap up into final third phase after a week of personal bests with 14-year-old Dynasty. “So I couldn’t be more happy; he came out a million dollars today, and apart from getting a little bit nervous to the last, he was brilliant.”
This isn’t Hector’s first time at this event with the gelding: they came in 2020, though picked up 20 penalties across the country on that occasion. Still, their completion gave them a chance to experience Pau’s tough final phase, which helped Hector prepare for the job at hand today.
“It’s always very big here, and today’s course was probably even more technical than last time I was here,” he says. “Everything was related in it, and it did make getting the time quite difficult, because if you even shut off for one stride it gave you time. When the leaderboard is as close as it is, that makes quite a big difference. I’m very glad I could afford my one second over, because I’d be kicking myself otherwise!”
For Hector, who began his career riding for William Fox-Pitt, from whom he inherited Dynasty after William’s accident in 2015, this moment is the culmination of a huge amount of work and a lifetime of dreaming — not to mention a long recovery from a badly broken femur last year. Now, though, he reckons he’s winning a long-standing argument with his mentor: “I’ve had an ongoing dialogue with William that started years ago, because Dynasty and Little Fire were the same age. Now, William’s go to better me — I always said mine was the better one!”
“I’m absolutely thrilled with him,” he continues. “His owners trusted me to bring him out here; we debated Burghley for a long time, but I really felt he could come here and be competitive. I wasn’t quite expecting to be that competitive, but we’ll take it! I haven’t been on a podium in a very long time, so I hope I remember what to do!”
David Doel and Galileo Nieuwmoed. Photo by Tilly Berendt.
Cross-country leaders David Doel and Galileo Nieuwmoed were struck by an impossibly frustrating bit of bad luck when the final fence came down, but their great efforts throughout the week still earned them a very respectable fourth-place finish, capping off a year that also saw them take sixth at Badminton.
“We came with the aim of being in the top three, so fourth isn’t too bad,” says David. “I was absolutely stoked with his round; he jumped mega all the way, and I don’t think I really would have done anything different to the last fence. Even when I re-ride it in my head, I don’t think I really tightened. He jumped fantastically — the warm-up was so good, and everything was spot-on.”
David certainly wasn’t the only rider to tip the final fence, which came as part of a fiendishly difficult line at the end of a lengthy course.
“He opened you up over the water tray and over the oxer, and then you had two big oxers all the way down the line, as well, so to finish with a really small, lightweight vertical on a left-handed turn was tough. But that’s what makes that 0.1 of a difference.”
Caroline Powell impresses with the youngest horse in the field, Greenacres Special Cavalier. Photo by Tilly Berendt.
When Caroline Powell first made the decision to bring her nine-year-old Greenacres Special Cavalier to Pau, she wasn’t sure if she might be mad — but, she reasoned, the experience would be valuable for the talented young mare, who finished third in the Blenheim Eight- and Nine-Year-Old CCI4*-S last month.
“The whole thing was to try and get ready, hopefully, for Paris,” says Caroline, who finished fifth after delivering one of the three clears inside the time. “As an eight-year-old she made a few mistakes on cross-country, but she’s just got better and better as a nine-year-old. She’s come out and just been amazing; at Blenheim she was fantastic, and we thought, if we don’t keep pushing her, then she’s going to start switching off — because she’s bright. She’s far too bright in herself, and she just loves to work. I think the horses like that, you’ve got to you’ve got to make most of them while you’ve got them, because they’re a long time coming.”
Like most great mares, ‘Cavvy’ is a character in her own right, and now that she’s on side, she’s becoming a ferocious competitor, too.
“She’s sort of a queen bee in the yard,” says Caroline. “No one can walk past her box without her coming over the door. She’ll pick a person by it every day, so you just sort of take a number! She wouldn’t be the best out hacking, but she loves the treadmill. I mean, she’s just a worker — jumping at home is quite fun! She’s a quirky old bird, but her dressage has got better and her cross-country’s so much better. She’s always jumped well; she loves to jump, and she’s just gone from strength to strength.”
Caroline Powell and Greenacres Special Cavalier. Photo by Tilly Berendt.
One of Cavvy’s greatest strengths is that she loves an atmosphere, something that Caroline discovered when piloting her around Le Lion d’Angers as both a six- and seven-year-old. That paid dividends for her today as she entered the bustling, vibrant arena.
“She loves a crowd, and she thought everyone was there for her today, which is even better. They’re unique, those ones.”
Like Grappa Nera ahead of her, Cavvy has become an exceptional competitor off the back of a rather wild and wooly youth, and plenty of patience from her rider and owner Chris Mann.
“It’s pretty special,” says Caroline. “As a five-year-old she actually went to Burghley [Young Event Horse], and we managed to eliminate ourselves in the five-year-old class because the jumping was so bad. She had the power, she just didn’t know how to use the power. And so we’ve had her for a long time, and I think when you you’ve known them for that long… she’s always jumped, and the mistakes she’s made have never been scary mistakes, she’s just been too long and too big. She’s as long as a boat, and when the power starts taking over the front end, you get in trouble. But she seems to have all that mustered and under control now!”
Bubby Upton makes it happen with Cannavaro. Photo by Tilly Berendt.
“It’s been so great to be back at Pau,” says a damp-eyed Bubby Upton after the clear round inside the time with Cannavaro that secured her sixth place. “This is where I made my [five-star] debut, and I love it here.”
Her excellent finish — and the unique honour of being the first rider to make the time and jump clear today — is made even more special after a tricky year, which saw her and ‘Joey’ lead the dressage at Luhmühlen but fall on cross-country. Their redemption began inauspiciously, with an uncharacteristic 33.3 in the first phase for 25th place, but adding just 4.8 time penalties yesterday allowed them to leap up the standings to overnight ninth.
“The week started off great, and he felt fantastic, but Thursday, I was really, really disappointed; he does a fantastic test, and he did that with one big error, but I feel like he was really unfairly marked in the dressage, as do quite a lot of people,” says Bubby. “So obviously, in the back of my head I’m thinking about what could have been — but whatever! He’s been truly phenomenal all week, and I can’t fault him. He was unbelievable out there on cross-country — not many people know, but he had ten weeks off after Luhmühlen, so he’s only jumped four times since June! So for him to come here this week and do what he did just shows what a heart of pure gold he has, because he shouldn’t have performed like he has.”
Bubby Upton and Cannavaro. Photo by Tilly Berendt.
The gelding, who formerly showjumped, was perfectly suited to today’s tough track, which gave Bubby no end of confidence as she came in to tackle the final phase.
“Today, I wouldn’t want to be sat on any other horse. He’s a class act — I got on him and I just felt so at ease, because there’s not an eventer that jumps like him out there,” she says.
Now, she can enjoy a restored sense of confidence in herself and her system, too: “I let him down at Pau [last year], and we were a bit of a mixture of my fault and a little bit of bad luck at Luhmühlen [this year] when we lost the win, which was an incredibly tough pill to swallow on the back of Badminton. For him to get the result this week means the absolute world, and I just hope to go five better next year! I’ve learned this year to trust my gut and trust my horses, because I know them better than anyone else.”
Maxime Livio and Carouzo Bois Marotin. Photo by Tilly Berendt.
Though Maxime Livio didn’t quite pin down the clear round his enthusiastic fans were urging him towards, his one-rail round with the ten-year-old debutant Carouzo Bois Marotin still looked very impressive — particularly as the gelding hasn’t had many clear rounds yet in his FEI career, though not for lack of ability. Their rail dropped them just one place to seventh, and the son of Kannan out of a Flipper d’Elle mare looks set to take his rightful place in Maxime’s A team of superstars in the seasons to come.
Emily King and Valmy Biats. Photo by Tilly Berendt.
Like Bubby and Cannavaro, Emily King and Valmy Biats came to Pau with a point to prove after a tricky week at a five-star previously. Their wobble came at Badminton this spring, where the Selle Français impressed in his debut but had a late fall on the way home across the country. This week, they put Badminton to bed, taking eighth place after tipping one rail today.
“He’s shone in every phase, really — he’s been amazing,” says Emily, who has featured in the top ten after every phase this week. “He was exceptional today; he’s such a good jumper. One of the things that makes him a super cross-country horse is that he’s so scopey and so brave, so it’s just been about reining in that bravery over the knockable poles.”
Learning to do so has been one of the silver linings of that Badminton fall, Emily explains.
“He’s probably learned a lot from it, because the only thing that would be his hindrance is his boldness. It’s a quite exaggerated lesson to be learned, and I think you probably don’t want it to happen too often, but I think it has just made him respect everything a bit more and made it obvious to me that it was literally the only thing that I needed to guard him from in cross-country and showjumping. We’ve definitely used it to learn from.”
Though their rail today didn’t lose them any ground on the leaderboard, it did cost them the chance to move up to sixth — though on balance, Emily isn’t planning to waste time on regrets.
“I thought that line might be our one, and in hindsight, I just needed to work a bit more — but I was thinking just now that it’s easy to be disappointed, but he was amazing. If someone had said to me that we’d be eighth before we came, I’d have been like, ‘okay!’ It’s only my second time riding him in a long-format event, so actually, with all those things, you get to know them more. So I’m really chuffed.”
Luc Chateau and Viens du Mont. Photo by Tilly Berendt.
France’s Luc Chateau made it three in the top ten for the home nation with Viens du Mont in the thirteen-year-old Selle Français’s five-star debut, tipping just one rail along the way to put a cap on an exceptional week that has seen them climb from first-phase 44th place to a final ninth.
Kazuma Tomoto and Brookpark Vikenti. Photo by Tilly Berendt.
Japan’s Kazuma Tomoto rounds out the top ten after a three-rail round with Brookpark Vikenti, which dropped him from overnight fourth but still kept him well in the mix as a result of the high number of faults amassed across the class today.
That’s all for us from Pau — for now, at least! — and so we bid adieu to the 2022 European season, to the south of France, and, for tonight, to you. Go Eventing.
The top ten after a nail-biting finish to the 2022 edition of Les 5 Etoiles de Pau.
Xanthe Goldsack and Hi Tech. Photo by Tilly Berendt.
This week’s coverage of Pau on EN is brought to you with the support of Kentucky Performance Products. We couldn’t do much of what we’ve done these last few years without the support of sponsors such as KPP — which, by the way, is a horses-first, women owned and operated company based in, you guessed it, Kentucky — and without you, our readers! So as we head into this final hurrah of our season, too, we thank each and every one of you.
Just 36 competitors will head into the final phase at Les 5 Etoiles de Pau this afternoon following a dramatic final horse inspection, held before the ground jury of President Sue Baxter (GBR), Anne-Mette Binder (DEN), Xavier Le Sauce (FRA).
Matt Flynn and Wizzerd. Photo by Tilly Berendt.
Four horses ultimately went to the holding box, with two of those returning for a successful re-presentation: Italy’s Pietro Sandei and his stalwart Rubis de Prere (28th) and the USA’s Matt Flynn and Wizzerd (30th) were given the go-ahead, while British debutante Xanthe Goldsack was first asked to trot again with a looser rein in her initial presentation of Hi Tech, then sent on to the holding box. She opted to re-present, but was sadly eliminated — likely an aftereffect of a lost shoe on course yesterday, where she was clear but with 48.4 time penalties for overnight 34th place. Her fellow British rider in the holding box, five-star barrister Max Gordon and his Redwood Clover (35th after cross-country), chose to withdraw, which marks the second time that the pair have seen their five-star end on Sunday morning.
Karim Laghouag and Triton Fontaine. Photo by Tilly Berendt.
Two further horses were asked to trot again immediately in their initial presentation, both as a result of some misbehaviour on the jog strip: both third-placed Karim Florent Laghouag and Triton Fontaine and Harry Meade and Tenareze (26th) had a job on their hands to deal with the huge atmosphere from the packed grandstands, but both were given the nod after those cursory second trot-ups.
Overnight leader David Doel waits with his two horses, Ferro Point (left) and first-placed Galileo Nieuwmoed (right). Photo by Tilly Berendt.
Here’s another look at the top ten going into this afternoon’s showjumping finale, which commences from 3.00 p.m. local time (2.00 p.m. British/10.00 a.m. EST). With less than a rail separating the top five, and with Pau’s reputation for building the toughest five-star showjumping courses in the world — there’s just a 17% average clear rate here — it’ll be a seriously exciting bit of sport:
The top ten after an influential day of cross-country at Pau.
This week’s coverage of Pau on EN is brought to you with the support of Kentucky Performance Products. We couldn’t do much of what we’ve done these last few years without the support of sponsors such as KPP — which, by the way, is a horses-first, women owned and operated company based in, you guessed it, Kentucky — and without you, our readers! So as we head into this final hurrah of our season, too, we thank each and every one of you.
Every time someone refers to twisty, turn-y, tight-timed and atmospheric Pau, with all its skinnies and corners and accuracy questions (and the odd swimming rat in the water) as the ‘soft’ five-star, I can’t help but laugh a bit — because never yet in the five years that I’ve been covered it for EN has it been anything close to an easy competition. Often, we see a leaderboard so tightly packed that even if the only influence comes from the tough-to-grab time, that’s enough to see huge changes — but most years, including this one, it serves up wall-to-wall action. Though today’s completion rate of 80.9% might look high on paper, its 62% clear rate is much more closely aligned with the historically ‘tough’ five-stars, and with just four of yesterday’s top ten remaining at the business end of the leaderboard, the Pierre Michelet course certainly did the job it set out to.
Though, as predicted, the first combination — a sizeable log drop to a corner at 4AB — caused plenty of influence, with eleven competitors running out the side door at the B element, it was very nearly eclipsed by a particularly efficient set of MIM clips much later on in the course. They featured as the B element in the middle water at 21B, which was an open corner equipped with the more sensitive yellow clips, four strides after another hefty hanging log drop. Nine competitors in total picked up 11 penalties for activating those clips, including dressage leader Felix Vogg and Colero, as well as Mollie Summerland and Charly van ter Heiden, who had been fourth going into today’s action.
David Doel achieves a career highlight, taking the overnight lead after a fifteen-place climb with Galileo Nieuwmoed. Photo by Tilly Berendt.
The first of the nine to activate those clips was David Doel, who was fourth out of the box with his first ride, Ferro Point, and reached the B element on a half-stride, kicking out the rails. But sometimes, eventing’s sense of kismet works in funny ways: having made that early mistake, he was well-prepared to nail the line, and that final stride, when he came back out as the last rider of the day with the Dutch-bred Galileo Nieuwmoed.
The eleven-year-old gelding (Carambole x Sjaloma, by Harcos) has been quietly proving himself as a serious talent for some time: he finished inside the time here last year, and was sixth at Badminton this year — but still, by the time David was counted down in the startbox, the pressure had been piled on. So much had changed through the course of the day — and particularly, in the final batch of riders, which saw Felix drop out of the lead, third-placed Tom McEwen and Bob Chaplin and second-placed Izzy Taylor and Monkeying Around both opt to retire after a duo apiece of refusals in the early stages of the course — that despite his fifteenth-place position at the end of the first phase, David was suddenly, keenly aware that a quick clear would give him the lead.
If he felt the pressure, though, he never showed it. His ride through that influential MIM-clipped water complex was one of those masterclasses of focus and commitment, and the four perfect, balanced, attacking strides he got were a clear indicator that David, like all his vocal supporters in the crowd, knew that his time had come.
David Doel and Galileo Nieuwmoed. Photo by Tilly Berendt.
And boy, had it. Just four riders made the 11:00 optimum time out of 47 starters — France’s Luc Chateau was the first, with Viens du Mont, and fellow countrymen Karim Florent Laghouag and Maxime Livio each did it too, with Triton Fontaine and Carouzo Bois Marotin, respectively. But David’s round didn’t just squeak inside the time — he romped across the finish line a full nine seconds under, lodging the fastest round of the day, despite a serious technical hitch that could have made even catching it nearly impossible.
“I actually stuffed up my clock because as I left the start box, I hit it twice,” he explains. “By the time I realised it wasn’t running, I was about three or four seconds out on my clock, so I had to just sort of keep myself ahead of it a little bit, just to make sure that my stuff up at the start box didn’t affect us. So I didn’t actually realise [I’d made the time] until I was back and my mum told me!”
David, who stepped up to five-star here in 2018 and has since produced an enormously impressive six horses to the level, entered into a debate at today’s press conference about whether luck plays a part in how a week of eventing can go — and the man who has suffered a fair share of rubbish luck, including a slipped saddle in the showjumping at Luhmühlen this year that resulted in a very late elimination, argued that it certainly does have a role.
“I think you need a little bit of luck,” he says. “Sometimes you have a trip or a stumble on cross-country, and sometimes the horse falls over, and sometimes they stand up. So I think there’s definitely a bit of luck involved, but the majority definitely comes down to preparation — to the days, weeks, months, and years in the process of getting horses to this level. The good horses are well-prepared, and you don’t often see someone get lucky and win a five-star — so it’s a bit of a mixture of both [luck and preparation].”
Certainly, though, those years of hard work, which have seen David run a yard alongside the family ice cream business, are the primary factor — and so the 29-year-old couldn’t be more delighted to relish the moment for now.
“[Leading a five-star is] a huge goal, and it’s been on the cards,” he says. “He’s a fantastic horse, and I’m very lucky to ride him. He’s athletic, and he has the power. he should have gone to Burghley, and we did a lot of prep for that, but then he had a bit of man-flu before Burghley, so he’s come here really fit and feeling fantastic. It’s a massive team effort — it’s not just my trainers that are out here, my granny’s out here, and the owners, and my mum and dad, and [for all of us], it’s been years and years of working to get him to this position. He’s been close, and so it’s lovely to be rewarded.”
Though the gelding jumped a classy clear on the final day at Badminton this spring for sixth, last year, he tipped two rails here — and so David is remaining pragmatic ahead of tomorrow’s competition and focusing on the variables he can control — namely, making sure his horse feels as good as he can do.
“Tomorrow’s going to be another day,” he says sagely, “but we’ve got great help, and the British team have been fantastic, so we’ll hopefully get him feeling as fit as possible for tomorrow.”
Jonelle Price’s Grappa Nera steps up to the big leagues with a swift, decisive run and overnight second. Photo by Tilly Berendt.
“I could have been [clear inside the time] number five,” says Jonelle Price ruefully, reflecting on her 1.2 time penalties with Grappa Nera. “I’m afraid it’s my fault — I could have been inside the time, but I had the three seconds, and that was my undoing today!”
But although those three seconds cost Jonelle the overnight lead, it’s a scant loss: she sits second with the five-star sophomore on a score of 31.3, which puts her just 0.7 penalties, or less than two seconds on the clock tomorrow, behind David.
Grappa Nera, who has gone under the radar at one-days for her propensity for naughtiness in the first phase, has come out of a spate of time off for an injury as a real contender — and although her primary role this year was as a back-up horse for the World Championships at Pratoni, Jonelle had long earmarked Pau as an event that could suit her perfectly.
“All the five-stars have their own unique flavour, and Pau is certainly unique,” she says. “It’s not the biggest of the five-stars, but the time is always influential because the woods really slow you down in the first and last third of the course. You need a nimble, athletic horse, but some of the distances that appear aren’t really suited to that type of horse, and you’d want something a bit bigger and scopier. I thought I had the perfect candidate in Grappa Nera: she’s very nimble and athletic, but some of those distances were pretty good for me, and luckily there’s another option there.”
Karim Laghouag and his Olympic partner Triton Fontaine lead the way for the home side and sit third overall going into the final day. Photo by Tilly Berendt.
There’s probably no man in France more popular than the ebullient, jovial Olympian Karim Florent Laghouag, and never more so than when he gives fans the chance to see his most recent Olympic partner, Triton Fontaine, in action. Those fans’ enthusiastic support was rewarded in kind today (and truly, you could chart his progress around the course from their screams of encouragement alone) with a speedy clear two seconds inside the time, hoiking him right up the leaderboard from 19th to overnight third.
“He gave me an amazing ride, and when he’s like that, he could do a six-star,” says Karim with a smile.
Kazuma Tomoto and Brookpark Vikenti move into fourth place. Photo by Tilly Berendt.
Japan’s Kazuma Tomoto is one of the sport’s real stylists in this phase, and his efficiency and prowess — and that fourth-place individual finish at Tokyo last year — belie the fact that he only began eventing less than six years ago after a career in the showjumping arena. Just a smattering of weeks after a top-ten finish with Vinci de la Vigne at the World Championships, he journeyed to Pau with a very different horse in Brookpark Vikenti. Though we’ve not seen the gelding at this level since 2019, when he led the dressage at Luhmühlen but ran into trouble across the country, and though he sat out much of 2020 and all of 2021, he’s been solidifying every skillset along the way, picking up a number of placings — and a win in his prep run in the CCI4*-S at Little Downham. That time and patience paid dividends today, and the pair go into the final day in a strong fourth place, just 1.4 penalties off the lead after adding 6.4 time.
Hector Payne and Dynasty climb into the top five after a storming clear round. Photo by Tilly Berendt.
Hector Payne sits fifth overnight after what felt like a coming-of-age round for the 14-year-old KWPN gelding Dynasty, who was campaigned in his early years by Hector’s former employer Willian Fox-Pitt, and who Hector inherited the ride on after William’s accident in 2015. This is the pair’s fourth five-star start, and their second trip to Pau — but the first time that, in every phase so far, the gelding has felt like he’s finally hitting the targets that they’re able to set at home. Their week began with a personal best score at the level of 30.9, which put them into 16th place, and their round today, which was clear with just 1.2 time penalties, was a sea change from their educational 20 penalties here in 2020 and their slow, steady clears at Burghley in 2018 and Badminton this spring.
Their newfound competitive bent comes after a trick year or so for the rider, who suffered a crashing fall while riding at a one-day event last year, resulting in a badly broken femur that ostensibly healed quickly, but has left lingering longer-term muscular damage that Hector has been working hard on with a physio.
“The first 80% of healing happened quickly — it’s the last 20% that’s felt like it’s taken a year,” he says, adding wryly, “I’m only allowed to do one-leg exercises in the gym!”
We chatted to Hector after his dressage test about the course to come, which he laughingly described as “Chris Bartle’s dream: he’s always telling us to ride everything as though there’s a corner three strides later, and here, there is!”
Maxime Livio and Carouzo Bois Marotin take overnight sixth in the horse’s level debut. Photo by Tilly Berendt.
There are few riders as efficient across the country, regardless of which horse is beneath him, as Maxime Livio — and at Pau, which is always packed to the rafters with a vocally enthusiastic home crowd who effectively carry their riders home with cheers of ‘Allez! Allez!’, there’s an even more noticeable buoyancy to the way he pilots his horses. That was evidenced today in his ride with the ten-year-old debutant Carouzo Bois Marotin, who came here with limited experience — though two top-ten finishes in as many CCI4*-L runs — but crossed the finish line looking like a truly established top level horse. They added nothing to their first-phase score of 35.1, catapulting themselves a remarkable 29 places up the leaderboard from 35th to sixth.
“He’s only ten, but I did two four-star longs with him, and this year in Saumur when I crossed the finish line with him still pulling the reins I thought, ‘shit, he’s ready for bigger sport!'” says Maxime. “So I let him have a rest for a little bit in the middle of the season to let him prepare for here. I was a little bit disappointed with the dressage, but even if he has a great ability for the test, he’s still very sensitive in his mind, so I can lose him a bit in a test. It’s his worst test of the season, but the atmosphere is different [to what he’s used to], and I’d really like to finish this competition well, because for me, if I do well today and tomorrow, then all I need to do is school him to learn that the dressage can be an easy job for him, too. Then, next year, I think I’ll have a real five-star horse.”
His ride today certainly buoyed his convictions in the gelding: “I didn’t have to work hard, because he’s really quick in the gallops, but also at the jumps. So on the twisty parts, I was quite fluent and up on time, and when I came back, I was still on my time. And I let him breathe a little bit for the last loop of the water which is quite twist and you can’t go fast, so I use that moment to say, ‘that’s a good job’. But then even in the last minutes, he was asking me to go for more. He’s quite an amazing horse.”
Caroline Powell’s Greenacres Special Cavalier may be the youngest horse in the field at just nine, but she’s one of the most impressive, too, jumping a confident clear for seventh. Photo by Tilly Berendt.
When we spoke to Burghley winner and seasoned Olympian Caroline Powell after her dressage, she confessed that she’d initially wondered if she might be mad to bring her preternaturally talented nine-year-old, Greenacres Special Cavalier, to Pau, rather than waiting until next season for the step up. But, she reasoned, even if they couldn’t be competitive this week, the exposure and experience would still serve as an important foundational and educational milestone for the mare, who has long looked set to be one of Paris 2024’s major contenders.
As it happened, though, they went a few better than that. Despite her inexperience, the nine-year-old mare sunk her teeth into the Pierre Michelet track as though it was a particularly good meal, and along the way, the pair were able to take calculated risks and add a relatively scant 8 time penalties to their first-phase score of 27.7. That sees them go into the final day in seventh place — one spot higher than they were after the first phase.
Emily King and Valmy Biats shake off their Badminton demons with an excellent round for overnight eighth. Photo by Tilly Berendt.
After completing three-quarters of Badminton’s exceptionally tough track this spring with her then-debutant Valmy Biats, Emily King knew she was sitting on a horse with the scope and guts to succeed at this level — even if he didn’t quite have the mileage yet. And so it was particularly refreshing to see that the Selle Français gelding, who is owned by breeder Philippe Brivois and ‘run’ by the Event Horse Owners Syndicate micro-syndicate group, hadn’t suffered any obvious loss of confidence after his unlucky late fall there — and that Emily, who enjoyed such extraordinary success on her own five-star debut here back in 2016, when she finished fourth, was able to repeat her fate of old today. They sit eighth overnight after an exuberant, bold round with 11.6 time penalties — a drop of three places from their first-phase fifth, but one that Emily isn’t wasting a moment regretting.
“He was just foot-perfect,” says a delighted Emily. “He was very strong and very brave — I nearly could have had two gears left on the straight, and I could have gone for it, but I didn’t want to overdo it and then him get tired and have a mistake. I really wanted to use it to see where he was at — and he just cantered home so easily. Every fence was perfect; he was just amazing.”
In fact, as Emily explains, much of the time she accrued was actually intentional, with two eyes firmly set on the future.
“He was so quick with his legs and made all the distances I’d planned,” she says. “I was planning to go one extra stride [in a combination] at the beginning, purely because he’s so brave. He could have gone one or two strides less if I let him, but I didn’t want to let that gain on him and then at the end have him be too keen, because that’s what led to the only mistake he’s had [previously]. I think like I could have gotten flat out and been a bit riskier, but actually, I wouldn’t have really learned much from it.”
Bubby Upton and Cannavaro tick all the boxes for ninth. Photo by Tilly Berendt.
So much has changed in a year for Bubby Upton, who made her five-star debut here last year with this week’s ride Cannavaro and her Badminton partner Cola. Then, she had a storming clear on the latter but opted to retire Cannavaro on course after an early issue, and this year, her five-star campaigns have largely been something of an educational experience — an odd irony considering that over the last number of years, she’s been successfully eventing alongside completing her degree, which she finished this spring. At Badminton, she picked up a frustrating run-out at the final fence with Cola after an exceptionally classy effort around the tough track, and at Luhmühlen in June, the former show jumper Cannavaro led the dressage, but showed his sporting roots across the country, jumping ever higher and more carefully until he effectively went into orbit over a drop combination, resulting in their elimination. A 14th place finish at Burghley with Cola marked a turning point — and Cannavaro’s turn has felt inevitable.
But there’s never been any doubt that Bubby would tick the boxes she did today at this level. The former Junior and Young Rider European Champion is a fierce competitor and, of course, a committed learner — and every frustrating moment she’s had this year was channeled, today, into the round the pair have long deserved at five-star. She and ‘Joey’ made light work of the analytical track, delivering that coveted clear and adding just 4.2 time penalties to move from 25th after dressage to overnight ninth.
“It’s probably one of my proudest rounds I’ve had, because I’ve let him down twice now and he so deserves to show everyone how classy he is,” says an emotional Bubby. “Although I was very disappointed with his mark in the dressage, I wasn’t disappointed with him — he’s just incredible. Last year, I messed up; Luhmühlen, I messed up. And today, I feel like I did him justice, and we showed everyone what we can do.”
Bubby, who now has valuable mileage over four of the world’s seven five-star tracks, rated today’s Pierre Michelet effort as among the most difficult she’s ever tackled.
“It was so tough out there. It was one of the toughest I’ve ridden — Burghley was tough physically on me, because I was having to keep plugging Cola along, but the intensity of this track, I’ve never written anything like it. So I’m so proud of how we handled it.”
“It was just one of those courses that you had to ride by the seat of your pants and by feel,” she says. “I’m one that always goes out with a set plan; I’m like, I want to know if I’m doing it on three or four or five or six. But as soon as I get out there it all goes out the window and I ride by feel. I know that that’s what works for me; having a plan mentally, knowing I have it, and then just going by feel. It paid dividends today.”
One of the major boxes that Bubby ticked with Cannavaro today was that of speed — something that’s not come naturally to the gelding.
“He’s never gone the trip before. I’ve said it time and time again that I never knew if he was ever going to make the distance. And actually, he had 11 weeks off after Luhmühlen, just in the field, because he injured his knee when he fell — so he jumped for the first time on the 22nd of September. That’s just a month ago, so for him to go around like that means more than anyone could know.”
Felix Vogg and Colero are one of several pairs to pick up 11 penalties in the second water complex, losing them their first-phase lead but only dropping them to tenth. Photo by Tilly Berendt.
Though Switzerland’s Felix Vogg attacked the course with the serious focus and gumption we’d expect from the Luhmühlen winner, he and Colero sacrificed their first-phase lead when they, too, were victims of those tender clips in the racecourse water. They added a further 3.2 time penalties for coming in eight seconds over the optimum time, but such was the influence of the day that even those 14.2 total additional penalties only dropped them as far as tenth overnight.
Matt Flynn and Wizzerd. Photo by Tilly Berendt.
Our sole US representatives, Matt Flynn and Wizzerd, picked up twenty penalties at 10A, a skinny in the first water, but nailed a completion, which sees them sit 30th overnight on a two-phase score of 83.3.
Tomorrow’s final day of competition kicks off at 12.30 local time (11.30 a.m. British/7.30 a.m. EST) with the final horse inspection, followed by showjumping from 15.15 (14.15/10.15 a.m. EST). Keep it locked on EN for all the news and updates, and until next time: Go Eventing!
The top ten after an influential day of cross-country at Pau.
This week’s coverage of Pau on EN is brought to you with the support of Kentucky Performance Products. We couldn’t do much of what we’ve done these last few years without the support of sponsors such as KPP — which, by the way, is a horses-first, women owned and operated company based in, you guessed it, Kentucky — and without you, our readers! So as we head into this final hurrah of our season, too, we thank each and every one of you.
Felix Vogg and Colero. Photo by Tilly Berendt.
Yesterday’s short dressage session at Pau, which saw just 17 of the 50 combinations make their way around the main arena, served as something of an appetite whetter – and today’s jam-packed line-up truly was the full meal. There are just two five-star winning combinations in this field, which set up a match race of sorts, and at the close of play, both are within inches of one another — but it’s this year’s Luhmühlen winners, Felix Vogg and Colero, who reign supreme on a score of 24.2.
But although the fourteen-year-old Westphalian gelding is a stalwart campaigner for the Swiss rider, who has piloted him around the World Championships in 2018 and also finished sixth with him at Kentucky in 2019, he’s still thrown a few surprises Felix’s way this summer.
“I was really nervous, because since Luhmühlen, he’s been really nervous in tests, like at Strzegom two weeks ago,” he says. “I think it’s because he did the prizegiving at Luhmühlen, and that’s not his thing at all! Yesterday, he completely freaked out in here.”
Despite a rather sparkly preparation, though, Colero cantered down the first centreline with his professional hat firmly in place.
“When it matters, he stays with me,” reasons Felix. “Usually he’s always too calm — he’s not usually allowed to do familiarisation, and I didn’t do that in Luhmühlen at all, but he needed it here!”
That meant that, despite a couple of lost marks in the halt and reinback due to tension, they were able to execute a valuable clear round and impress the ground jury, who have proven to be tough nuts to crack this week.
“All the way through was quite okay, and the walk was quite good for him — sometimes he’s a tiny bit nervous. The medium canter was very good, I think,” he says.
Though his five-star win at Luhmühlen was a milestone moment for him, and for Swiss eventing, which hasn’t seen a five-star winner since the 1950s, Felix is remaining level-headed under the weight of expectation this week.
“It starts from the beginning again — it’s like before Luhmühlen. Probably some other people expect something, but for me, he’s done enough.”
Izzy Taylor and Monkeying Around. Photo by Tilly Berendt.
A perfunctory glance out at the schooling arena yesterday yielded a bit of excitement, if you happened to have that glance when Izzy Taylor was riding her Bramham CCI4*-L victor Monkeying Around: the exceptionally talented dressage-bred gelding spent a fair amount of time demonstrating his extraordinary athleticism, in a way that Izzy no doubt hoped he’d avoid in the main ring. But, as Izzy explains moments after her musical, fluent test, part of getting to the bottom of this tempestuous talent has been letting him have his ‘moments’, so that when the real deal rolls around, he’s ready to crack on and give his best work.
“He’s a character, and you have to work with that,” she says with a grin. “He likes to have fun, and everything’s very easy for him, so you have to make the preparation harder so that when he’s in the ring he’s like, ‘oh, this is easy!’ and he’s happy, he’s smiling, and he loves life.”
That joie de vivre was evident in his work today, which had none of the extra dance moves we’ve sometimes seen in four-star tests — and in his hotly-anticipated five-star debut, Monkeying Around pulled it out of the bag, putting a 24.4 on the board and taking a close second place at the culmination of the first phase.
“He’s a very characterful horse, so if I can bring the character into the ring, then it’s great — but I need to make sure we’ve had our chat beforehand,” says Izzy, who, despite her gelding’s relative experience at this point, hasn’t yet ridden him in an atmosphere of this scale. “I suppose Bramham has an atmosphere,” she says, “but he’s never really been anywhere because of Covid and life, I suppose, so he did come in here and go ‘ahh!’ I was like, ‘you need to breathe!’ and then he grew and smiled the whole way through. I was very pleased with his brain.”
Just one tiny error precluded an overnight lead: the first change came a touch early, earning them 4s at H and B.
“It’s annoying with the change — he went early in front because he was so eager to please, and you can’t fault them for that,” she says. “But I’m so proud of him; he’s a beautiful horse, and it’s special when you have them from the word go.”
Tom McEwen’s second ride, Bob Chaplin, gives him two in the top ten at the conclusion of the first phase. Photo by Tilly Berendt.
2019 Pau champion Tom McEwen goes into cross-country with two horses in the top ten: his day one pathfinder, Braveheart B, sits ninth on 28.3, while today’s ride, the exquisite grey Bob Chaplin, takes third overnight on 24.6 after a real clear round test.
“He was a really good boy,” says Tom, who opted to scale back the gelding’s schooling prior to his test, with great success. “Harriet [Fettes, my fiancee] has hacked him; he’s been out looking at the racehorses every morning, and he did ten minutes of arena familiarisation and that’s literally all he’s done. He can get a bit bored and irritated if you kick him around a school, so however much you want to work on bits and bobs, you’re better off leaving him alone.”
Both of Tom’s horses come to Pau with a point to prove after an unlucky week at Luhmühlen in June, where Bob Chaplin fell at the penultimate fence as a result of an errant dog on the course, and Braveheart, too, took a tumble. Tom, though, is a stoic soul and a lifelong learner, and while he’s not dwelling on the past this week, he’s certainly found things he can improve upon from that week — namely in that warm-up routine.
“[Doing too much before dressage is] the mistake I made at Luhmühlen with him, when he feels a little bit perky — but he’s also been on the road for two weeks now, so he’s seen enough,” says Tom, who brought both horses to Le Lion d’Angers with him last week so he could keep them in work as he competed his young horses. “He does very limited stuff at home, too — he does twenty minutes of schooling and then goes hacking, so we can keep him nice and happy and fresh.”
Though Tom is sitting on a horse with a very low 20s score within him, he tempered his expectations in the ring today, instead focusing on laying firm foundations for all that’s to come with Fred and Penny Barker’s eleven-year-old.
“I knew he could do a good test, but apart from the first change, which we messed up, it was a clear round,” he says. “I know he’s expressive and he can go and do all these amazing things, but he’s just not yet strong enough to do that in a test. So for me, it’s more important to go and do that nice, clean test, rather than worrying about how expressive he can be, because we know it’ll come.”
As one of just four riders with two rides here, Tom had the rare opportunity to feel out the difference in the arena surface, which was watered heavily overnight and had a noticeably shallower cut underfoot today, resulting in easier, more fluid rides and, arguably, a slightly less taxing route to great marks.
“It’s good that they listened to feedback, but it’s a shame it couldn’t have happened a day earlier,” says Tom. “Realistically they’re beaches that are maintained with water, and yesterday, there wasn’t enough water, so it was like the tide had been out for a good couple of hours — whereas today, it’s back to a normal Pau surface.”
Mollie Summerland and Charly van ter Heiden dance their way to a close fourth place. Photo by Tilly Berendt.
The ground jury certainly hasn’t been giving marks away freely today, and never was that more keenly felt than in 2021 Luhmühlen champions Mollie Summerland and Charly van ter Heiden‘s test, which was wholly mistake-free and elegant but just saw them slip out of a potential lead on a final score of 25, just 0.8 off first place.
“He felt really rideable, and it was nice that they’d just rolled the arena, so there was some spring to it,” says Mollie, who trains on the flat with dressage supremo Carl Hester and is reliably a force to be reckoned with in this phase. “He did everything I asked, and maybe one change wasn’t as expressive — I think I rode it a bit safe, but I was really happy with the way he went. He had a good brain in there, and he didn’t take much work outside, so it’s nice to know that I’ve got some left in the tank for tomorrow.”
Emily King and Valmy Biats. Photo by Tilly Berendt.
There was a very jolly scene in the chute after Emily King‘s test with Valmy Biats, who remains under the ownership of France’s Philippe Brivois, who also bred the gelding, but is also ‘co-owned’ by the successful Event Horse Owners Syndicate, which provides affordable micro-syndicate memberships for eventing enthusiasts, many of whom turn out at events near and far to watch their horse strut his stuff. Today, they were rewarded in kind with one of the 13-year-old’s best-ever tests, which demonstrated his burgeoning strength and earned him and his rider a 25.5, slotting them into fifth overnight.
“He’s just getting better and better, which is so nice,” says Emily. “You don’t really know where the end’s going to be with him, because every time he goes out, whether it’s a one-day or an international, he just keeps getting better. He’s got a really good brain on him, and he finds the lateral movements very easy, it’s just that he can get a little bit hot in there, so it’s all about keeping him calm.”
Though he’s thirteen, Valmy is still learning his job — and one of his big learning curves has been the flying changes, which didn’t just look good in the ring, but also looked newly well-established in the schooling ring, where EN’s roving journalist admired him earlier on in the day.
“He’s only just started doing the changes properly this year, so they’re getting more and more established, but they’re not quite beautified — but this is one of the first shows where he hasn’t missed many in the warm-up, so everything’s getting more consistent,” says Emily, who is supported this week by mum Mary King and boyfriend Sam Ecroyd, and returns to Pau for the first time since finishing fourth in her five-star debut here in 2016 with Brookleigh.
This is the gelding’s second five-star: he made his debut at Badminton this spring, where he was one of several good horses to be caught out late on course at the Mars flower boxes — but already, Emily is seeing a huge improvement in his work as he begins to understand the nuances of what he’s being asked.
“He’s very supple naturally, and the changes, he can jump them a bit — he knows what he should do, and he tries to do all this extra stuff to help him, which actually doesn’t,” she explains. “So it’s just been about polishing the changes and getting him really rideable — all those little things that’ll step him up again.”
Valmy is a big, rangy boy to look at, rather than the whippet-like French horses that we so often see on the continent, and that, too, has contributed to affording him a touch more time to establish himself at the upper levels.
“He’s quite a chunky monkey, so he doesn’t get the elegance factor quite so naturally, so it’s been about getting him through and showing him off but keeping the basics understood, rather than showing off and little mistakes creeping in,” she says. “That’s the thing as he levels up — as he gets more established, he can get more elegant.”
Kazuma Tomoto and Brookpark Vikenti. Photo by Tilly Berendt.
Japan’s shining star Kazuma Tomoto is never a man to throw a mark away in a test, despite picking up eventing just over five years ago — and today, he delivered a characteristically sparkling performance aboard Brookpark Vikenti to earn himself a very respectable 25.6, which sees him hold sixth overnight. That moves day one leaders, Ros Canter and five-star first-timer Rehy Royal Diamond, into seventh place on their 27.3 in this tightly-packed top ten.
Caroline Powell and Greenacres Special Cavalier. Photo by Tilly Berendt.
The youngest horse in the field, nine-year-old Greenacres Special Cavalier, gave us one of the most enjoyable tests of the week, posting a 27.7 for overnight eighth with Olympian and Burghley winner Caroline Powell in the irons. That puts her six-tenths of a penalty ahead of Tom McEwen and Braveheart B, yesterday’s pathfinders, who sit ninth now on 28.3.
“She’s been on it all week,” says Caroline, who gave the expressive mare a sympathetic, nurturing ride that yielded some serious ‘wow’ moments in the ring.
But, like many seasoned producers of young horses, Caroline wasn’t always sure if the step-up was the right step.
“She’s only nine, and so you wonder if you’re a bit silly bringing them here, but if she makes a mistake, it’s going to be a glance-off or something. She jumps so well, and she’s never scared herself; she just needs to learn how to do the lines.”
Caroline Powell and Greenacres Special Cavalier. Photo by Tilly Berendt.
Though she came to Pau with the tempered expectations that come par for the course with a first-timer, Caroline always knew she was sitting on something that could produce a really special test — particularly as her mindset has shifted in the right direction over the last couple of seasons.
“She’s been doing some quite nice tests, and all week, she’s been with me. Once you get a mare on your side, you’re a wee bit further on. She loves her work; she’s a real workman, and that makes a real difference. Once she’s got something in her mind, she’s fine — but if she gets the wrong thing in her mind, then you’re in trouble!”
The pair go into cross-country tomorrow in an enviable position, just 3.5 penalties, or just under nine seconds, off the lead — but still, Caroline is maintaining a firm hold on her sense of pragmatism, because ‘Cavvy’ is a serious contender for big things in the years to come. Tomorrow, she reasons, will be an exceptional learning opportunity for the eye-catching mare, and whatever happens, she’ll benefit from the experience.
“She’s a big girl, but she’s getting better between the strings, and the more places she can go, the more she’s going to learn,” she says.
Kevin McNab and Willunga. Photo by Tilly Berendt.
Today’s first out, Australia’s Kevin McNab, was one of several riders in the field to pilot a mid-teens first-timer — and fifteen-year-old Willunga certainly stepped up to the plate, delivering a 28.9 that puts him in tenth place overnight. But his workmanlike behaviour in the ring belies a rather wild frat-boy past: his former rider, young horse aficionado Nicky Roncoroni, fondly remembered his early years in a celebratory Facebook post ahead of his performance.
“When perseverance is key,” she writes. “The most characterful little rascal to start off, causing no end of entertainment to anyone who had the pleasure of working with him. The early days were not the most simple, from marching off with people on the long reins, changes in direction quicker than a jump jet, frequently clearing collecting rings, knocking my two front teeth out & the first 3 events reading something like E/R3 145.60 and E/AR & we’re talking about BE80(T’s) [US Beginner Novice] here!”
“He’s a lot more professional now than he used to be,” laughs Kevin. “He certainly was interesting in his younger years! I think Nicky got a lot of that out of him, but there was still some there [when I got him]. He actually thought he was a proper boy, so he’d call out in his tests and he had a few little tricks — but he’s settled down a lot, which he should do, because he’s fifteen!”
Time has been the key for Willunga, who paid that back in full today.
“We’ve just had to get to know him, and figure out what works for him and the set-up. We’ve had to go at his pace, rather than our pace, and that’s meant it’s been a bit slower getting there.”
Though the atmosphere, which was bolstered by low-flying planes and nearby firing practice, certainly added an extra pizzazz factor to proceedings, Willunga remained almost entirely cool and collected, showing some real highlights in the test.
“His trot work is really fun to ride, and it’s really solid, so it was nice to be able to show that off a bit,” says Kevin. “The walk is always a little bit of a thing if he’s tense, and it was a little bit today. That carried on into his canter, but once we got going, he was back again and he made a nice picture.”
Matt Flynn and Wizzerd. Photo by Tilly Berendt.
We’ve got just one US representative in the field after the withdrawal of Caroline Martin and Islandwood Captain Jack from the holding box yesterday morning, and Matt Flynn, who’s been based with Tim and Jonelle Price in England this season, put in a solid effort with the stalwart Wizzerd to post a 35.7, which sees them go into cross-country in 34th place. That’s less than 12 penalties — or 30 seconds — off the leaders, and in a tightly-wheeled track like Pau’s, that’s a much smaller margin than it might sound.
“There’s always things you want to improve, but I was happy with the way he went,” says Matt sagely. “There’s still plenty to do this weekend, and we’ll give it a good shot.”
Tomorrow sees our competitors head into Pierre Michelet’s cross-country challenge, which will begin from 1.00 p.m. local time (12.00 p.m. British/7.00 a.m. Eastern). You can follow all the action live on Horse&Country TV, plus, stay tuned on EN for riders’ thoughts on how the course walks and what we might expect from the competition to come. These things are rarely dressage competitions, but with its abundance of corners and technical, analytical questions, Pau offers a particularly unique challenge, which should yield plenty of changes across our leaderboard and a seriously spicy day of five-star action. Keep it locked on EN — and until next time, Go Eventing!
The top ten after dressage at Les 5 Etoiles de Pau.
This week’s coverage of Pau on EN is brought to you with the support of Kentucky Performance Products. We couldn’t do much of what we’ve done these last few years without the support of sponsors such as KPP — which, by the way, is a horses-first, women owned and operated company based in, you guessed it, Kentucky — and without you, our readers! So as we head into this final hurrah of our season, too, we thank each and every one of you.
Tucked in as it is at the tail end of the season, Les 5 Etoiles de Pau can sometimes fly a touch under the radar — but that’s not really fair on this unique French five-star, nor the intrepid riders who tackle it. We’ve got a seriously exciting field this year, and we’re diving straight into figuring out what exactly makes it so compelling.
Yesterday, we took a look at the horses taking part in this week’s five-star — and today, our spotlight is wholly on the riders. Who’s the youngest in the field? How about the oldest? Which riders have a track record of success at this venue, and are men or women leading the way in the line-up? For all this and more, keep on scrolling.
This week’s coverage of Pau on EN is brought to you with the support of Kentucky Performance Products. We couldn’t do much of what we’ve done these last few years without the support of sponsors such as KPP — which, by the way, is a horses-first, women owned and operated company based in, you guessed it, Kentucky — and without you, our readers! So as we head into this final hurrah of our season, too, we thank each and every one of you.
Ros Canter’s five-star debutant Rehy Royal Diamond delivers the first day’s leading score as the last test of the day. Photo by Tilly Berendt.
From the tiny men dressed as horses (we’ll get to this, I promise) to the cross-country course that practically enters a Citroen dealership, everything at Les 5 Etoiles de Pau is done in its own unique way — and that certainly includes day one of competition. Unlike other five-stars, which host the trot-up on a Wednesday and dedicate Thursday to dressage, Pau takes more of a ‘bit of column A, bit of column B’ approach to proceedings — and after today’s first horse inspection, we dove pretty well headlong into a short, sweet session jam-packed with the horse-dancing stuff.
This afternoon’s action saw just 17 of the 50 competitors take a turn around the main arena — and along the way, just two would crack the 30 barrier. The lead was held through most of the afternoon by pathfinders Tom McEwen and Braveheart B, but at the very tail end of the day, they were pipped at the post by fellow Brit Ros Canter, who came forward as the last rider of the day and delivered the new leading score with debutant Rehy Royal Diamond.
“I’m absolutely delighted with him,” says Ros, who posted a 27.5 with the eleven-year-old Irish Sport Horse (Ars Videndi x Pegasus Star, by Diamond Lad), who she rides for owner Christopher Makin.
Though the gelding has proven an exciting talent, taking a top ten placing at Bramham CCI4*-L this season, he hasn’t always been particularly straightforward: “He’s not been the easiest to get his brain right on the flat,” explains Ros. “He just has a game, and goes on a bit of a jolly — like, ‘look at the crowd!’ He’ll change when he’s not supposed to do, or miss a change when he’s supposed to do one, and waggles around in his halts and jogs in his walks — he’s just a jolly fellow!”
Coming to a long-format event gives the gelding a chance to settle into his environs and perform at his best, she explains: “We need a three-day; his one-day results aren’t anything to go on, because he just needs to be in a place for a bit longer and get a bit bored by it.”
Getting a clear round in the ring was the goal of the day, and although Ros is realistic about her expectations for the week, it’s a starting point she’s very happy with.
“He pulled up completely mistake-free, which is pretty much unheard for him, so that’s great stuff,” she says. “[The highlight] was the way he just stood in his halts with his head so still, because that’s what we struggle with the most, and it’s quite a difficult thing to train with a horse, and it’s just a bit of a habit for him. So just the rideability in a change, and the fact that I could have my leg on all the way is a massive improvement for him.”
Now, both horse and rider will enjoy a ‘day off’ to prepare for Saturday — and once again, Ros is looking to take it one step at a time, always keeping the future in mind.
“It’s a bit of a fact-finding mission,” explains Ros. “I have no doubt about his scope and ability and generosity — it’s just that his build and shape mean that sometimes he runs out of balance, and he’s very long-striding. I’ve struggled in the past, towards the end of the course, to hold him — not because he’s wanting to gallop off with me, but because his length of stride gets a bit too big and I have to overcompensate and slow down quite a lot. So I’m fairly realistic: if we have a great experience, that will do for us. It’s just a case of, I’ll go as fast as I can, but hopefully in a safe way so that he comes home enjoying the experience.”
Pathfinders Tom McEwen and Braveheart B hold the lead for much of the day, but relinquish it at the eleventh hour. Photo by Tilly Berendt.
Though Tom McEwen was usurped from top place with Braveheart B, his first of two rides, he didn’t slip by much: the pair’s 28.3 sits them in second place, just eight-tenths of a penalty behind the leaders going into the second, fuller day of dressage. For the twelve-year-old Irish Sport Horse (Radolin x Buenos Aires, by Heartbreaker), it’s the first time breaking the 30 barrier since 2019, when he did so in the CCI3*-L at Tattersalls. At four-star level, he’s been a pretty consistent mid-30s scorer — but although today’s tidy test undoubtedly earned its final score, Tom’s assessment was that it was on much the same par as his previous five-star performance at Luhmühlen back in June.
“He went really well at Luhmühlen, going in early, and actually, he produced a really similar test there,” says Tom, who scored a 31.6 on that occasion. “He did as well as he could do and tried as hard as he could, and all we can ask for is for them to try as hard as they can.”
Still, though, he was delighted to tick every box in the ring with the rangy gelding, who’s owned by Barbara Cooper.
“The changes, for him, would be highlights — they can be a little small compared to the others, but for him, they’re very nice,” he says. “There’s some nice work in there — he can hide a little bit behind the vertical at some points, but overall, he showed a really nice test and outline and gave us a solid, safe clear round.”
The trick to coercing a competitive score out of the gelding hasn’t been any magic button solution, he explains, but rather the long, slow process of building him up with correct foundations. Getting to school him in unique atmospheres, too, has been a blessing — which meant that his early trip to France, accompanying Tom’s ride in the Seven Year Old World Championship last week, paid dividends.
“It’s all coming; it’s just his strength. He’s taken a bit of time,” he says. “He actually came to Le Lion with us last week, and that was really good for him — just seeing the atmosphere, and working on the surfaces, which at Le Lion, are a bit softer than what you’d expect at Pau. So just getting him working through his body and running through the tests around other horses; it’s one thing doing it at home and another thing doing it a show.”
Jonelle Price and Grappa Nera curb their enthusiasm for overnight third. Photo by Tilly Berendt.
Less than two weeks after her husband, Tim, won Maryland’s CCI5*, World Number Two Jonelle Price put herself in a competitive early position, taking provisional third place with the diminutive, expressive Grappa Nera on a score of 30.1 despite mistakes in the changes. That’s a considerable upgrade from her previous five-star score of 35.6, which she earned at Kentucky last year — but, as Jonelle explains, she’s not been the easiest horse to produce.
“She’s been a bit of a livewire, but it feels like there’s a light at the end of the tunnel,” she laughs. “The changes aren’t quite there yet, so you don’t expect to magically go and pull them off, but to sit on a thirty with four bad changes reflects on the quality of the rest of the work, so when — if! — I can get it, it’ll be good.”
Like Ros’s ride, Grappa Nera is at her best when she’s able to settle into a new location, and her best scores — such as the 30.5 she earned at Strzegom CCI4*-L in 2020, which ultimately helped her earn second place — have come at long-format events.
“She regularly does a 50 at a one-day — she’s a true three-day horse,” says Jonelle. “She needs to work and she needs to settle into an environment, but she is eleven, so she’s growing up a wee bit, hopefully, so hopefully we’ve got a few good years ahead of us.”
Gireg Le Coz and Aisprit de la Loge dance their way to a day one top five despite some disappointing moments. Photo by Tilly Berendt.
France’s Gireg le Coz leads the way for the home nation after putting a 30.4 on the board for overnight fourth place with Aisprit de la Loge — but the expressive twelve-year-old Selle Français gelding (Quppydam des Horts x Image de la Loge, by Dollar du Murier) has so frequently been a mid- to high-twenties scorer, including at Badminton this spring where he earned a 26.7, that Gireg couldn’t help but feel the sting of disappointment after his test.
“I’m not really happy,” he says. “I think he was feeling very good in the warm-up and good in there — there were just some uncharacteristic mistakes that normally doesn’t happen with him. I had a nice feeling when I started, and then there were just a few little mistakes in the canter. I don’t really know why, so I’m disappointed.”
Disappointed though he may be, it’s never over until it’s over — and Aisprit de le Loge, with his short-coupled build and easy manoeuvrability, is a horse who’s made for Pau, as he proved when winning the now-defunct CCI3*-S here back in 2018.
Izzy Taylor and Happy Days. Photo by Tilly Berendt.
Izzy Taylor rounds out the top five overnight on the first of her two rides, the five-star debutant Happy Times. At just ten years old, the British-bred Sport Horse is among the least experienced horses in the field, but he delivered a mature, promising performance to earn a 31.7, just losing a minor smattering of marks in the second flying change and the stretchy canter circle.
“I think did the best he can do with where he is at the minute,” says Izzy. “He’s a first-time five star horse with not a lot of mileage, and he came and did everything. He had a clear round, basically.”
Time, too, has been key with Happy Times, who has had to learn to carry himself in balance but has, this year, picked up promising placings as a result, including fifth place in the CCI4*-S at Burgham.
“He’s lovely, but he’s quite a big horse, so there’s a lot of him to manoeuvre and he’s actually very bendy, so actually translating that to having the legs in the right place… he wants to do it right, and then he gets into it and he can’t,” says Izzy.
Tomorrow sees us dive headlong into a fully-stocked day of dressage, with 33 tests to be performed from 10.00 a.m. local time (9.00 a.m. British time/4.00 a.m. EST), with Australia’s Kevin McNab and Willunga first in the ring. As always, you’ll find all the biggest stories of the day right here on EN — so tune in for all the news that’s fit to print. Until then: Go Eventing!
The top five after day one’s first (short!) day of dressage at Pau.
This week’s coverage of Pau on EN is brought to you with the support of Kentucky Performance Products. We couldn’t do much of what we’ve done these last few years without the support of sponsors such as KPP — which, by the way, is a horses-first, women owned and operated company based in, you guessed it, Kentucky — and without you, our readers! So as we head into this final hurrah of our season, too, we thank each and every one of you.
Japan’s Ryuzo Kitajima and Feroza Nieuwmoed. Photo by Tilly Berendt.
Is it just us, or is time moving differently in the aftermath of the pandemic? Les 5 Etoiles de Pau, which takes place in the shadow of the Pyrenees in the south-west of France, is one of those special events that managed to run throughout the turbulent last couple of years, and perhaps for that reason, it’s beginning to feel like EN’s de facto second home. It’s somehow been a full year since we escaped a torrential downpour just after Tim Price’s big win here with Falco, but we will not believe it. We won’t. Accepting the passing of time means we must accept our own mortality, and that’s a minor crisis that no one needs on an overcast Thursday morning. Ennui might be very French, but a full on existential breakdown is surely beyond the pale. Let’s get back to the horses, shall we?
Matt Flynn and Wizzerd make a last minute leap onto the Pau line-up. Photo by Tilly Berendt.
This morning saw the competition kick off with the first horse inspection, which is almost always held on Thursday, rather than Wednesday, at this event. There were some last-minute additions to, and withdrawals from, the entry list before it began: 2019 Burghley winners Pippa Funnell and MGH Grafton Street will no longer contest this week’s competition, nor will Tim Cheffings and Gaston and the USA’s Katherine Coleman and RLE Limbo Kaiser. We’re excited to welcome another US representative, though, in Matt Flynn and Wizzerd, and Austria now has an entry in Katrin Khoddam-Hazrati, who rides five-star first-timer Pippa 2.
Max Gordon and Redwood Clover. Photo by Tilly Berendt.
Our final start list now sits at 50 competitors after no small amount of drama at this morning’s first horse inspection, which was held before the ground jury of President Sue Baxter (GBR), Anne-Mette Binder (DEN), Xavier Le Sauce (FRA). Two horses were asked to trot again immediately after presenting, but subsequently accepted without a trip to the holding box — first of those was Redwood Clover, the sophomore five-star mount of Great Britain’s Max Gordon, who has had quite a trip to Pau after travelling directly from a wedding in Dubai. The second was another British pair in Harry Meade and the debutant stallion Tenareze, who cantered his way back down the strip and was thus given another opportunity to show the correct pace.
Emily King and Valmy Biats. Photo by Tilly Berendt.
A further two horses were sent to the holding box, where fortunes were considerably more mixed. Emily King and the exciting Valmy Biats, who had a late fall at Badminton this spring, were accepted upon re-presentation, while we were sad to hear the news that the USA’s Caroline Martin, who has been enjoying an exceptional season in England based with Pippa Funnell, opted to withdraw Islandwood Captain Jack from the box.
“He’s just a little body sore from two weeks of travelling and being stuck in a stall,” explains Caroline, who has been competing in France over the last couple of weeks with a successful run at Le Lion d’Angers last week — an end-of-season adventure that always requires competitors to bring their five-star horses out for the full shebang.
Fortunately, Caroline’s got a great sense of perspective about the disappointment: “We’ve had an unreal season and I get to go home with happy horses,” she says.
Caroline Martin and Islandwood Captain Jack. Photo by Tilly Berendt.
This week’s competition brings forward a bumper field of entries, including five-star winners Felix Vogg and Colero (Luhmühlen 2022) and Mollie Summerland and Charly van ter Heiden (Luhmühlen 2021); this year’s Bramham CCI4*-L victors Izzy Taylor and Monkeying Around, who makes his five-star debut as one of the hot favourites in the field; British under-25 National Champions Greta Mason and Cooley For Sure; Luhmühlen runners-up Kirsty Chabert and Classic VI; and French fan favourites Karim Florent Laghouag and Triton Fontaine, who were twelfth individually and team bronze medallists at the Tokyo Olympics.
Luhmühlen victors Mollie Summerland and Charly van ter Heiden return to Pau, where they were tenth in their five-star debut in 2020. Photo by Tilly Berendt.
The dressage will commence at 2.30 p.m. local time this afternoon — that’s 1.30 p.m. if you’re watching from Great Britain and 8.30 a.m. if you’re on the East Coast. Our first pair of today’s 17 competitors in the ring will be Tom McEwen and the first of his two rides, Braveheart B, while our sole remaining US competitors, Matt Flynn and Wizzerd, will come forward at 10.42 a.m. (9.42 a.m./4.42 a.m. EST) tomorrow. You can check out the times in full here, and to tune into the livestream — with a cheeky 15% discount! — click here.
We’ll be back soon with plenty more from France’s weird, wonderful crown jewel — until then, faire du concours complet!
This week’s coverage of Pau on EN is brought to you with the support of Kentucky Performance Products. We couldn’t do much of what we’ve done these last few years without the support of sponsors such as KPP — which, by the way, is a horses-first, women owned and operated company based in, you guessed it, Kentucky — and without you, our readers! So as we head into this final hurrah of our season, too, we thank each and every one of you.
And just like that, the 2022 season was over — or nearly, anyway. We’ve got one last big one to sink our teeth into before the battening down of hatches and digging out of training manuals and DVDs, and it’s one of our favourites here at EN. Welcome to the sultry south of France and weird, wonderful Les 5 Etoiles de Pau, where we’ve got a sizzling field of horses and riders from 11 different nations coming forward to fight for the prize — including five-star victors, some of the best debutants in Europe, Olympians and young riders alike.
It all kicks off tomorrow at 10.00 a.m. local time (9.00 a.m. British time/4.00 a.m. EST) with the first horse inspection, which will be followed by a short afternoon session of dressage — so to get you into the spirit of the thing, let’s take a glimpse at the stats of the 50 horses who will come forward this week.
Tim Price’s Coup de Coeur Dudevin digs deep again to take his first five-star win on his debut. Photo by Tilly Berendt.
After a Saturday that split opinions, it’s been enormously exciting to have an action-packed afternoon of influential competition at the MARS Maryland 5 Star.
Though our top three would ultimately remain unchanged after cross-country, the short and sweet showjumping finale was jam-packed with action and excitement, with a beefy, technical course of 16 jumping efforts. Both the time and the course itself — which featured jumper-style lines including a rollback turn between fences 8 and 9, followed swiftly by a sharp square turn to a treble combination at 10abc — proved influential, and just five of the 21 starters would deliver faultless rounds.
Cross-country leader Tim Price wasn’t one of them. He came into the arena with less than a rail in hand over Tamie Smith and Danito, who had just delivered an exceptional clear, adding 0.4 time to stay just one-tenth of a penalty ahead of Oliver Townend and As Is, who had added nothing in their round. Like Tamie and Oliver before him, he cantered through the starting line on an unseasoned five-star debutant and, again like those before him, crossed the finish on a newly-established superstar. In doing so, he took his fifth five-star title — won, quite remarkably, aboard a fifth different horse.
“I’m very proud of Coup de Coeur Dudevin,” says Tim of the ten-year-old Selle Français, who he rides for breeder Jean-Louis Stauffer. “In fact, I think all three of these top horses are incredible. It’s exciting for the sport; it’s exciting for us personally; and it’s just so unexpected to have a top result like this. I came in hoping that I would have a top-five finish with this horse, but I expected there would be a couple of things that showed his lack of experience. Luckily, we were able to do that while keeping a nice, low score.”
Tim Price and Coup de Coeur Dudevin. Photo by Tilly Berendt.
Tim’s goal this week has been to educate the young horse, who was originally produced by Switzerland’s Robin Godel and, latterly, Chris Burton, before briefly joining wife Jonelle’s string last year. It was that modus operandi that allowed the rider to keep his cool coming into the pressurised final phase.
“It’s been so tight at the top through the week, starting from the dressage — and these guys have been there and got the t-shirt many times of what it’s like to be in the final few and the pressure that comes with it,” says the newly-crowned World Number One, who came here fresh off the back of a win at Boekelo with Happy Boy. “I knew there would be some flawless rounds at the top of the table, and that was kind of what kept me from falling asleep and woke me up early in the morning. I was ready for that and in a way, with my young horse at this level, I almost hid behind his lack of experience and just went into the mode of educating him and giving him a good time. But of course when you get in the ring and you know that the clear round inside the time is key, you go into performance mode. I was just really happy he dug deep for me. It’s a new depth of stamina requirement for him, and he really went into that ring and just lit up and busted himself for the job. That’s very exciting, for what a horse he’s showing me that he is, and for the future for him. To nail a victory like that, I’m just very, very proud of him.”
“It’s just to great to have such a good rider,” says owner Jean-Louis Stauffer. “We’ve known the horse from his first day, and I think we did it right in the way that we never forced him. He was never pushed to do something he couldn’t do, and he’s got this brain where he wants to get over the obstacles; he wants to be good. That’s a very good horse.”
Jean-Louis isn’t just the horse’s owner — he’s also his breeder, though he refuses to take all the credit there.
“It’s not me who made the match; that was Richard Levallois from [Haras de] Semilly,” he explains. “I went with a mare, and he asked me what I wanted from the horse. I said, ‘it must have a good force, good strength in the back’. And if you saw this horse, in the dressage he was almost kicking the ass of Tim Price to the front! He’s a very good one.”
‘Joker’ could have become part of a breeding programme in his own right, but flunked out at an early age due to some personality quirks.
“I had to have him castrated because he was very impatient — he wanted to go with the other horses. Castrating him just brought him into the team,” says Jean-Louis. “I think from the first day he was born, in the box he would make contact with you and then always be positive.”
Bringing a largely unproven ten-year-old all the way across the Atlantic Ocean for his five-star debut was always going to be a gamble, but when Tim expresses a quiet, unshakable confidence in the gelding to his owner, Jean-Louis backed the idea completely.
“Tim said, ‘I feel it’, and I said, ‘if you feel it, we’ll go.’ It’s just my way of doing it — as an owner, you shouldn’t intervene too much,” he says. “I never would have thought I’d have a horse coming to the States, and then, okay, you think that because of the expense, it’s good if they don’t come all this way just to be eliminated on the cross-country. But the rest? It’s all equal: there are horses that win, and horses that don’t win, but as long as they progress well, and as long as they do well, I think it’s good. It doesn’t mean they must win — we’re the winners today, but we’re not necessarily going to be the winners all the time!”
Tamie Smith and Danito log their first clear showjumping round since 2020 at the perfect moment. Photo by Tilly Berendt.
It’s been one heck of a year for second-placed Tamie Smith, who gave it her all in her efforts to keep the Maryland title in US hands with Ruth Bley’s 15.2hh first-timer Danito. Although the diminutive 13-year-old Hanoverian is a force to be reckoned with on the flat and across the country, before this weekend, he’d not made the time in a long-format since his second-ever CCI2*-L, nor had he kept the rails up in an international since 2020. But with plenty of guts and gumption on his side — and on that of his plucky Californian rider, too — he made both things happen here, adding just 0.4 time today to his first-phase score of 29.4.
“I actually haven’t even produced a clear round on Danito at CCI4*-L — but we kind of all joked that he broke his wither this winter and it gave him another two feet over the jumps,” laughs Tamie. “But he really has come out outstanding, and he really jumped out of his skin. There was a couple of places where it definitely didn’t go to plan, but you go as quickly as you can to to Plan B. He’s such a mighty little horse and he tried his guts out, soI’m super proud of him. The ring would be difficult — it’s small and things come up quick, and so it was good to produce that result.”
The result caps off a year that’s gone from one mishap after another to something of a dream come true for Tamie.
“It hasn’t been the fairytale year that you might think,” says Tamie, who was part of last month’s silver medal-winning team at the FEI World Championships, and who also took a top ten finish at Badminton this spring with top horse Mai Baum. But earlier in the year, it didn’t look as though she’d get any of her goals for the season ticked off.
“California in my area was infected with EHV this winter. I got out of there right before that and went east, but then I promptly broke my ankle and tore all the ligaments in it. I could just see my dreams kind of fading away. I didn’t think I’d be in contention for the World Championships, but I also wouldn’t take no for an answer.”
“The first three months of 2022 was a disaster for me. My horse had broken his wither on top of everything else, so to have the fall season that I’ve had from Pratoni on has been really special. I have a huge, wonderful support team, and I know that we’re all just ecstatic about this accomplishment.”
Tamie Smith and Danito. Photo by Tilly Berendt.
Her best-ever five-star finish isn’t the only affirmation Tamie got from her result today: finding herself between two of the most prolific competitors in the world was also a particularly special feeling.
“These guys are legends in the sport, and it’s an honor to be up here with them,” she says, nodding to Tim and third-placed Oliver. While they’ve been career winners nearly from the beginning of their careers, Tamie’s finish is a different kind of testament to resilience: she began her path to the top after working her way through college as a young single mother, making her hard-won result a beacon of hope for aspiring competitors whose lives have followed a trajectory that’s not quite linear. In a way, it feels a little bit as though she’s won — and no doubt, that moment is coming soon.
“I did say to Tim, ‘you couldn’t have had a frickin’ rail?!’,” she laughs.
Oliver Townend and As Is round out the top three with a sterling clear round inside the tough time. Photo by Tilly Berendt.
Four combinations managed to finish on their dressage scores in this year’s field, and the highest-placed of those was Oliver Townend, who, like Tim, has recorded a podium finish in both runnings of this new event. Though his eleven-year-old Spanish-bred Sport Horse As Is occasionally looked a bit green in the ring, and gave the fences a fair amount of airtime as a result, they stayed on the right side of the clock to take third place, climbing from first-phase tenth through the weekend.
As Is, who was formerly campaigned by Andrew Nicholson, is owned by Sir John Peace of Caunton Stud, for whom Oliver began riding earlier this year.
“I’m highly delighted with him, and [this result] is very special for me — it’s the first time I’ve had a job since I was 21, so to deliver results for the people that are employing me for the first time this year is very special to me,” says Oliver. “There’s a lot of people behind the scenes at Caunton, and at home at Gadlas, so it’s been a very different year this year for me — but one that’s just been so, so positive.”
Oliver began riding As Is just this spring, and has had a spate of exciting results with the gelding already, including a placing at another Ian Stark-designed event at Bramham CCI4*-L in Yorkshire.
“For us to deliver the result that we thought he was capable of… you never know, he’s a new horse and it’s five-star, so anything can happen,” he says. “He went out a little bit green yesterday and a bit careful and I just thought last night, ‘well, let’s just hope he’s as careful in the show jumping tomorrow as he is on the cross-country course, and we’ll be alright’.”
This isn’t the first horse Oliver has taken on from longtime friend and mentor Andrew, from whom he’s previously inherited top horses such as Cillnabradden Evo, Swallow Springs, and Armada — but today, he knew he had a particularly stellar jumping record to live up to.
“I actually felt a little bit of pressure,” he says. “I said to Andrew Nicholson on the phone that I used to feel no pressure going into showjumping on Armada, because we all knew he used to destroy the place, but to know that you’re on such a good jumper, it was down to me to press the right buttons and get the right distances. But he was, I think, very, very special in the ring today, and it’s just hugely exciting for my team at home and the new team at Caunton that we have a horse of this caliber.”
Phillip Dutton and Z take fourth place. Photo by Tilly Berendt.
It felt a little bit like 2008 at Kentucky all over again when Phillip Dutton and Z crossed the finish today, well inside the time and clear to boot. Though that didn’t quite clinch them the win, it did allow them to take fourth place, a healthy climb from the eleventh place slot they’d occupied after posting a 30.5 in the first phase.
“He’s a great jumper, it’s just that sometimes we lose a little bit of the rideability because of tension,” says Phillip, who was delighted to find that the experienced 14-year-old Zangersheide felt well-settled in the atmospheric main arena after a great warm-up with show jumper Lauren Hough. That was particularly necessary, because the unique arena and tough course at Maryland demanded so much of the horses while constantly testing their focus.
“It rides harder than it walks, certainly size-wise, and it’s all pretty related and a smaller arena,” says Phillip. “I mean, I think every venue is a little unique; you know, all the five-stars throughout the world. And this is unique: it’s a bit smaller, but the really good horses win anyway. The atmosphere is great.”
Even more moving than the excellent result was the memory of his late coach and mentor.
“I was a little bit emotional because my good friend Richard Picken was here last year, and Michelle Kauffman said to me, ‘it’s bringing back memories’ — so I started to flood over, but luckily I was able to pull it back together,” says Phillip. “He was a great friend, and my showjumping coach, and he had a big influence on me.”
Jennie Brannigan and FE Lifestyle step up to fifth place. Photo by Tilly Berendt.
Jennie Brannigan put a cap on an excellent week with her duo of rides, finishing fifth on her dressage score of 31.5 with FE Lifestyle and sixteenth after a trio of rails with Twilightslastgleam, both of whom she rides for longtime owners Tim and Nina Gardner.
Jennie Brannigan and FE Lifestyle. Photo by Tilly Berendt.
Having two rides in the class allowed her to make great use of the intel she gleaned the first time around with her second ride, FE Lifestyle — but those were just two of many rides she had this week, a decision that, in hindsight, might have been a touch too much.
“I’m exhausted,” she laughs. “Riding five horses here was probably a little ambitious! But it was a beautiful week, and this is my hometown event, so it’s been great.”
Will Coleman and DonDante. Photo by Tilly Berendt.
Sixth place went the way of Will Coleman and DonDante, who had a frustrating, rare rail but nevertheless climbed from 10th place after cross-country, on which they were clear inside the time yesterday.
“I’m obviously bummed about the pole, but my horse tried really hard,” says Will of the 12-year-old Irish Sport Horse, who was fifteenth here last year and seventh at Kentucky this spring. “I think he didn’t have his best stuff today — he was a little stiff from galloping up all those hills yesterday. But he gave me everything he had and just toed one, and I can’t be too upset. It is what it is, and you do what you can do. I’m very pleased, and now we’ll look to the future and try to be better.”
For DonDante, who came to Fair Hill to compete in the Young Event Horse Championships as a five-year-old, it’s a full-circle moment to come back here and finish in the top ten — and a testament to how productive the young horse pathways in the US can be.
“It’s cool; it’s very gratifying. I really enjoy that,” says Will, remembering that first trip here with the gelding. “You know, we’ve had most of ours we’ve had since they were young, which does make it pretty rewarding, and each step you get like a little adrenaline from. Then they do their first three-star; they do their first four-star… I think that’s cool, and I think we’re just constantly trying to get better at raining them well and bringing them along confidently and happily. It’s a big part of what makes this whole game worth doing.”
Harry Meade and Superstition put a positive spin on a tricky start to the week. Photo by Tilly Berendt.
Great Britain’s Harry Meade had a tricky start to the week with Superstition after a disruption to his warm-up meant that the horse was nervous and reactive to the point of explosiveness in the dressage ring, scoring an enormously uncharacteristic 37.4 to sit 21st. An easy clear inside the time yesterday, though, boosted the pair up to fifteenth — and though the relative lack of influence of Saturday’s competition precluded a higher climb, today offered a stiff enough challenge to see significant movement on the board. That meant that their clear round inside the time today was enough to catapult them to a final seventh place.
“I’m thrilled with the horse and thrilled with how he was all week,” says Harry. “Sometimes, you’ve got to make just make the best of the hand you’re dealt; we didn’t have a nice time in the build-up to the first phase, but that’s by the by. You forgive and forget.”
Harry was one of several riders to levy constructive criticism at the event, particularly for its uninfluential cross-country phase, a trend that continued on from its inaugural running.
“The cross-country, like last year, was a bit of a non-event,” he says. “I can’t fault my horse; he was absolutely beautiful, and that’s a long way to go to not even scratch the surface — he feels as though he’d be great to go to Pau in two weeks’ time! But it’s always lovely to finish on a clear showjumping round — it means everyone goes home on a high.”
Today, though, he was pleased with the influence and difficulty of the course.
“You want the jumping phases to separate the really good horses, and this was a really interesting course,” says Harry. “One to two was quite open, and actually, the terrain in the arena is more extreme than you might think, so heading down to fence five was super short. It didn’t walk short, but it rode short. Then, after the treble, you had to turn up to the square oxer — it was a big fence up a hill. It was a great course and it sorted them out — we saw such a high standard of jumping out there, and it made for a great end to the competition.”
Allie Knowles and Morswood clinch Allie’s best-ever five-star result. Photo by Tilly Berendt.
Allie Knowles earned herself her best-ever five-star result, taking eighth place with the excellent Morswood after tipping just one rail late in the course. That’s her second personal best of the week: her first came in the dressage, where she earned her best five-star score, a sparkling 28.8 that put the pair into third place going into cross-country. Though their 6.4 time penalties dropped them out of contention into twelfth place, Allie was delighted to make the climb back up the order today — though already, she’s thinking about what’s next to work on.
“It was a great week, but I’m quite critical, so there was room for improvement in all three phases,” says Allie. “But that’s a could-a, should-a, would-a type of thing, and that’s my best result in a five-star. He did everything I asked, so I’m super happy overall, and I’ll be looking forward to the next opportunity to do it better! But it’s cool to know that I’m on a horse that’s so suited to doing something like Badminton in the future.”
Doug Payne and Quantum Leap secure ninth place. Photo by Tilly Berendt.
Doug Payne and Quantum Leap might be the most seasoned pure jumpers in the ring — in fact, most of the gelding’s competition mileage this year has come at jumper shows — but Ken’s tough course was tricky to conquer even for them. They tipped the first and had a pole down at the ninth fence, positioned on a rollback turn, but were ultimately able to stay in the ninth place spot they’d occupied after cross-country, wherein they’d added 2.4 time penalties.
Hannah Sue Hollberg’s veteran competitor Harbour Pilot bows out on a high in tenth place. Photo by Tilly Berendt.
Finally, the top ten was rounded out in fine style by Hannah Sue Hollberg and Harbour Pilot, who retired from competition at the impressive age of nineteen after his round, which saw him rub two poles but only slip two places.
“I’ve been riding him since 2008, so he’s been with me forever, and it’s weird to think about not competing him anymore,” says an emotional Hannah Sue, who has tackled eleven previous five-stars with the gelding. “He doesn’t feel his age at all — he feels the same as he did five, seven, ten years ago. He’s a tough horse, and I’ve tried to take care of him really well by not running him if the footing’s bad or if he’s not just right at the show.”
Hannah Sue Hollberg and Harbour Pilot. Photo by Tilly Berendt.
Hannah Sue had made the decision to retire ‘William’ at the end of this event well before it started, which meant that throughout the week, she was constantly reminded that each phase was her last with him by commentary over the tannoy. That announcement was exactly how her showjumping round began, too, which made the practicalities of actually jumping the course a little tough.
“I started crying before I started, which wasn’t very helpful!” she laughs. “But I didn’t really mind — I felt like that all week, and I was just proud to be on him and finish his career like that.”
Lauren Nicholson and Landmark’s Monte Carlo. Photo by Tilly Berendt.
Just one odd moment marred the afternoon’s sport: Lauren Nicholson, who had been sitting seventh with Landmark’s Monte Carlo, was awarded 13.2 time penalties in her one-rail round due to some confusion with the starting bell, and despite appealing to the officials, she was unable to get the penalties removed, which pushed her down to seventeenth place in the final standings.
“Patty produced a really lovely round today, but sadly his popularity resulted in confusion at the start,” writes Lauren in a post on her Instagram account. “Due to the crowds [sic] cheers, the bell was not heard by myself (and from what I understand, no one in the crowd either). Despite my multiple salutes, gestures of confusion, and asking the crowd if they had heard the bell, the clock was started and we were given a devastating 13 time penalties, knocking us from 6th place to the bottom of the field. After an extremely long discussion with the ground jury, which was headed by Christian Landolt, they decided that they would not remove the penalties. The ground jury acknowledged that it was clear that I had not heard the bell, and that I had made multiple gestures waiting for it to be rung. The head of the ground jury stated he could not have rung the bell a second time even if he wished to because it was not legal. Although, we presented them with a rule clearly showing they could ring the bell a second time at their discretion. Which he admitted to not knowing that rule but tough nuts for me.”
It’s been a beautiful — and educational — week of five-star competition in the sunshine here in Maryland, and already, we’re curious and excited about how this buzzy, vibrant new event will further develop for its third renewal next year. We’ll be back with more content from the weekend that was, but for now — Go Eventing, and Go Tim Price!
The top ten at the conclusion of the 2022 MARS Maryland 5 Star.
Overnight leaders Tim Price and Coup de Coeur Dudevin. Photo by Tilly Berendt.
Phew. Is there anything more bum-clenchingly tense than a final horse inspection? Even here at the MARS Maryland 5 Star p/b Brown Advisory, in which horses have enjoyed exceptionally good going and looked to finish brilliantly yesterday, this morning’s proceedings weren’t without dramatics.
Hannah Sue Hollberg and Harbour Pilot: the sole hold of the morning, but accepted on re-presentation. Photo by Tilly Berendt.
Just 21 of yesterday’s 22 finishers presented to the the Ground Jury of Christian Landolt (SUI), Gretchen Butts (USA), Judy Hancock (GBR), following the overnight withdrawal of Canada’s Lisa Marie Fergusson and Honor Me. Three horses warranted a second look during the course of the morning, though just one was sent to the holding box for further investigation and a second inspection: that was Hannah Sue Hollberg‘s nineteen-year-old Harbour Pilot, who sits eighth overnight on 31.8 in what will be the final event of their long, storied partnership.
Tamie Smith and Danito. Photo by Tilly Berendt.
Fortunately, we’re delighted to report that they were subsequently accepted into the competition, as were Jennie Brannigan‘s FE Lifestyle (6th on 31.5 and presented for his rider by Great Britain’s Harry Meade, who snuck a curtsey to the ground jury in there!) and Tamie Smith‘s Danito (2nd on 29.4), who were both asked to trot a second time.
Harry Meade tips a curtsey to the ground jury before presenting Jennie Brannigan’s FE Lifestyle. Photo by Tilly Berendt.
Our compact, classy field of 21 heads into the showjumping finale, designed by Ken Krome, from 2.00 p.m. Eastern time (7.00 p.m. BST/11.00 a.m. Pacific). Last year, we saw an influential final phase here, and the stage is certainly set for one again: there’s less than a rail between the top five, and less than two between the top twelve. To add to the excitement, each of our top three — leaders Tim Price‘s Coup de Coeur Dudevin, second-placed Tamie Smith‘s Danito, and third-placed Oliver Townend‘s As Is — are first-time five-star horses, none of whom will have tackled a challenge like this before.
It’ll be a real nail-biter, folks, but us EN-ers have always found special ways to cope with the nerves. We’re thrilled to announce that dressage leader Woods Baughman took us up on our hoedown challenge, and you’ll get to see the results — in all their arrhythmic glory — very soon. If we committed career suicide this morning, at least we went down swinging.
A look at the layout of this year’s Maryland CCI5* track.
THE ESSENTIALS
Length: 6555m
Optimum time: 11:30
Fences: 29
Speed: 570mpm
“Last year, with hindsight,” I must have been insane,” laughs MARS Maryland 5 Star course designer Ian Stark, who has delivered us a new-look, considerably tougher track for this year’s renewal. “It was my first five-star, and a greenfield site that had never been used. I didn’t know how the terrain would affect the horses, so I probably backed off more than I’d have liked. Some horses finished full of running and others were really, really tired, so I hope riders learned about the terrain and have their horses fit enough.”
One of the major changes that Ian has made is relocating the start and finish, which are now located in the centre of the course.
“That was the most important thing for me this year, and I think it gives the course a better flow,” he says. “It avoids them finishing up the hill from the bottom of the middle field almost right up to the main arena, which was a fair climb at the end of the course, and some of the horses finished really toiling at the end. So for me, this gives it a better flow, and also allows me to maintain the five-star standard all the way through. I felt from the bottom of the hill last year in that middle field, I had to back off — so it was a three-and-a-half to four-star on the way home. There were still technical difficulties, but I felt I couldn’t give five-star dimensions and big spreads, because horses would be getting weary.”
There’s plenty to see on the course — not least, a menagerie of inexplicable dinosaurs and one robust longhorn in situ on the track. But if you’re hoping this might be a nod to some sort of diplodocus discovery at Fair Hill, we’re sorry to report that their presence is just the result of Ian being, well, a bit weird.
“I kept driving past the dinosaurs at the garden centre down the road when we were going to Mario’s for lunch, and I said to [course builders] Tyson and Barney, ‘I want them on the course!’,” says Ian. “So they went in and chatted the guy up, and he delivered them for me, which was incredibly kind of him – they’ve got nothing to do with the course, but I love them, and they give people something to look at!”
Anyway, Ian, we like your style. And so, friends, we recommend giving yourself a bit of easy listening while you walk the course with us.
Fence 1.
The course begins on a patch of flat ground over a wide, welcoming table, but from the word go, riders will need to be on the ball: the galloping lane from 1 to 2 and thereafter runs parallel to the warm-up arena, which will be a tough test for horses who are prone to napping and want to stick with their pals.
“The start is on the top of the hill, so it’s a bit flat,” says Ian. “The first fence is off a bend, and I deliberately put it there because if anyone gets too sneaky and tries to cut around that corner, they could easily have 20 penalties by running out of the first fence. I’m kind of hoping that they’re on the case but they’re not getting too excited at the start.”
Fence 2.
There’s not a huge amount of space between fence 1 and 2, which makes it feel like a related distance — and it’s a downhill approach to the second fence, which is a relatively narrow trakehner. That’s a classic rider frightener fence, so it’ll encourage an attacking ride from the get-go — no bad thing when there’s plenty of major questions to come.
“To me it’s just an inviting, kick-on fence,” says the man who proved he has some of the biggest cajones in the sport when navigating the tearaway Murphy Himself around the world’s biggest courses. “I had planned to have it in the warm-up area, but when I walked down from the start, it was in the way, so it became fence two! So there was nothing really great in the imagination, and some of the riders were a bit concerned that there’s a ditch at fence two.”
This is the first sign on course that Ian has really stepped up the intensity — but it’s also a useful way to ensure that competitors are taking the job seriously in the first minute.
Fence 3.
From fence two, they move on to a classic five-star run-and-jump fence, which has a friendly rolled profile and a brush on top, and will encourage an attacking rhythm and a confidence-building bit of airtime.
“This is going to give them a real big feel – it’s a lovely fence that’ll get them way up in the air and running away on the landing,” says Ian. “They’ll be fairly travelling down the hill and around the corner to the first water.”
Fence 4A, with 4B visible on the other side.
The first chance to get their feet wet comes up quickly, and involves two skinny birds that are reminiscent of Luhmühlen’s famous Danger Tit, which was situated in the water at the 2019 European Championships and caused plenty of problems. These birds, though, are both on dry land, as Luhmühlen’s has been since 2019, and so shouldn’t be as influential — but they’re accuracy questions that do demand respect.
“It’s a friendly-ish first water but the birds are not to be ignored,” says Ian. “You need to take your time and jump them straight on and accurately. If you try for an angle you could easily leave a leg and get tipped out the side door. They’re not difficult, but they do need to concentrate.”
This first water also means that horses can land on the dry and then carry on into the water, rather than being expected to jump straight in — so done well, they’ll boost horses’ confidence and let riders fine-tune all those canter gears they’ll need further on in the track.
Fence 5.
When you get to the fence 5, a wide, brush-topped table, you get your first taste of the ‘no thanks’ — this thing is seriously big. Of course, if you have a touch of insanity running through your veins, you might feel a bit differently.
“What I would give to have a horse here to just gallop up to this on – it’ll give a great feel,” muses Ian, a man who’s made a fine art out of having admirable insanity in the bloodstream.
If someone has an unlikely mishap here, though, there’ll be no harm done: “It’s perfect ground — it’s like walking on a carpet! It’s amazing. Even if you fall off, it’s quite cushioned,” says Ian, startlingly unreassuringly. “But it’ll be great to just wing up to that and get a real good feel before you head to the arena.”
Team EN, thinking about the ‘real good feel’ this fence will give.
Fence 6.
New to the Maryland track this year is a tour through the main arena, which gives a continental feel to proceedings and allows spectators to pause from shopping to fill the grandstands – so expect a wall of sound and some serious atmosphere as they enter through the left-hand side gate.
Ian was keen to include this loop, but as he explains, not everyone was initially on board with his vision: “It’s the first time in the arena and it took a bit of persuading to get them to let me change the course around, and then a little bit more persuading to get them to let me go in one gate and out the other,” he laughs. “They said, ‘can you not get them in and out though the same gate?’, but I’m a pretty bloody-minded Scotsman, so I had to stand my ground! But they’re always very generous and incredibly nice to me here.”
The first of the three elements in the arena is a rolltop at six, which will give horses the chance to get up in the air without a mentally taxing question as they adjust to the fishbowl effect of being surrounded by enthusiastic fans.
Fence 7ab.
Pretty quickly, though, they’ll need to land and adjust, because as they turn to fence 7a — an enormous brush box — they’ll be gazing right into the hospitality stand, and they certainly won’t have time to peruse the open bar through the windows.
“When you approach the big brush box you’re looking straight into the grandstand, and some horses won’t notice the people, but others will be backed off,” he says. “A few of the riders have said that they’re thinking of sticking to the left of this fence and jumping a bit left to right over the first, which will get them to the second in three strides. What I’ve said to them is that the bogey here is this: you may plan the three strides, but if a horse is backed off and lands a bit steep, it may not be there. They’re going to have to be able to react to however the horses jump the first element, but I don’t anticipate problems.”
After that, it’s “a good winging out” of the corner of the arena and back down the galloping lanes in the direction they’ve just come from, and Ian hopes that they’ll take the opportunity to really travel — because the next combination they’ll meet will ask them to be really positive in their canter.
Fence 8ab.
Fence 8ab features a pair of bum-clenchingly big tables on an offset left-handed line, which is set on a long two-stride distance. The point here? To balance at speed, and have power, pace, and positivity on side — classic cross-country riding, in a nutshell.
“There’s two big strides there, so if anyone gets a bit showjumping minded, they’ll struggle for the two, so they need to be travelling – then they’re quite inviting,” says Ian.
Fence 9.
If they’ve ticked the boxes Ian wants them to at those tables, they’ll hit the ground running and be able to catch a couple of seconds on the clock as they travel down to fence 9, which is the first time we’re seeing MIMclips safety devices on the course. This time, they’re the classic red ones, which aren’t as easily activated as the yellow variety we’ll spot later on, and although there’s a pretty straight shot down from 8b to 9, there’s a little bit of a set-up turn to get straight to this, which will help riders get their horses back on their hocks to make a neat job of it.
“They have to jump in carefully, because of the clips, but I don’t foresee any problems here,” says Ian.
Fence 10a, with the direct b element just visible and the direct c, a narrow brush box, beyond it.
Taking the time to jump that oxer with care, and reassess how well they can get their horses sitting on their hind ends, will serve them well when they reach 10abc, which Ian tells us is the first major question on the course. It’s also a spot that offers a few options for those who don’t think they’ll make a tidy job of the direct route, which features a skinny box on top of a step mound, a downhill five-stride run to the middle of three brushes over a ditch, and then a three-stride line to a skinny brush box.
Fence 10bc — the direct route is the left-handed of the two brushes featured here, with the direct c visible behind.
“There’s a long route, and I’ve put a whole load of trees and pumpkins out to stop people mixing them up but they could still do whatever they want there,” says Ian, who has individually lettered each element, which means a mix-and-match approach wouldn’t result in a technical elimination.
Fence 11abc.
Once they’ve successfully negotiated that serious elevation change and accuracy question, it’s time for water number two — and this time, they nearly do have to jump into the drink. Or, at the very least, it’ll look that way to the horses, who’ll take a leap of faith over the first boat.
“The first boat is supposed to be on dry – it’s being worked on,” says Ian, who scaled back the dimensions of this fence after realising that maximising the size made it an almost unjumpably tough question.
“It’s a big jump in, with a big spread and a big drop. That was last year’s three-star fence in the water, and I tried putting a five-star fence there, but suddenly the course went from a five-star to a ten-star. Even I didn’t have a big enough pair of you-know-whats to do that! I’m expecting a big jump in over the A element, four strides to the boat in the middle, and then three to the lighthouse out at C. There’s an alternative B element if they scramble on the way in, but I don’t really anticipate them using it.”
Fence 12.
Would it be a five-star without a ditch and brush you could park a sedan in? We think not — and Ian agrees. We’re pretty sure the riders will be delighted to know that the brush side of fence 12, though, is significantly lower than it was just a few days ago.
“The other day it was 25cm higher than it is now, and it was a bit like trying to have a conversation with William Fox-Pitt — I was just looking straight up at it!” laughs Ian.
This’ll be an ‘easy’ run-and-jump fence, but for Ian, it was nearly the site of his own grisly demise.
“I’m completely superstitious,” he explains. “The first CCI4*-L I designed was at Bramham, and I found a four-leaf clover [while I was designing it]. Everywhere you go, except California, obviously, you can find clover in the grass, so I have to find a four-leaf clover. I was hunting for one while the boys were cutting the brush down, and after I found it, I got there and I said to them, ‘it’s too small — you’ll need to make it bigger!’ I think they thought about hitting me with their chainsaws!”
Though this is a ‘gimme’ fence, if such a thing exists in top-level eventing, the approach adds an interesting element here.
“The straight line has a rollercoaster approach ,which could muck up your distance — but if you come on an angle it’s a flatter approach. It’ll be interesting to see which riders have been paying attention there.”
A live view of Ian in the riders’ tent, watching to see which line they pick.
Fence 13.
There’s not an awful lot of time to think before they get to fence 13, and honestly, that’s probably for the best. This ramped rolltop, which has a downhill landing and a real ‘into space’ feel, is visually one of the most imposing single fences we’ve ever laid eyes on — but remarkably, Ian says, “it looks enormous, but it doesn’t even measure maximum height for a 5*!”
Fence 13.
Let’s take another look at this chunky thang, with EN’s Sally for scale. For context, she’s 5’5, and we’re all clenching our bums.
Fence 13.
And once more, for good measure, from the landing side. Thank you, but no.
Ian Stark, rn.
There’s an opportunity to catch up on the clock a bit after that absolute monster at 13, with a beautiful gallop stretch that’ll see them hit their six-minute mark — just over the halfway point — midway along it. What a nice opportunity to catch a glimpse of the fall foliage, maybe.
Fence 14.
After that galloping stretch, Ian has placed a capacious open oxer with MIMclips off a turn, which is a useful opportunity to get the horses back before the coffin complex, and should be used wisely.
“It’s just there to set them up for the coffin – I expect them to jump that and then get the coffin canter, which I’m always gone on about; that short, bouncy canter.”
Fence 15ABC.
That coffin canter, unsurprisingly, is the key element to jumping a coffin, which they get at 15abc. The direct route here makes savvy use of sharp terrain, with a MIMclipped rail on a slight downhill to the ditch at b, which is followed by a sharp uphill to a small log at c, which replaces last year’s brush.
“If they don’t set them up, they’ll be flying through there and probably dislodge the MIM at the coffin rail,” says Ian. “But the fact that they’re going downhill will mean that the horses are propping, so I’m expecting them to be really good there.”
If they do get a funny jump over the ditch, they can reroute around the mound to another log on the flatter ground, which will cost them valuable seconds on the clock.
The feeling of riding the coffin, encapsulated.
Fence 16AB.
There’s another short run to the next combination, a pair of colossal tables on a positive three strides to a left-handed brush corner four strides away at 16abc. Here, there’s an alternative option for the brush corner on the right hand side, but it’s only intended to be used after a run-out, as the line isn’t as clear if they try to tackle this directly from the second of the tables.
“There is a right option but for me, it’s only there for if they have a runout at the direct corner. I think they’d struggle to jump and turn right, because it’s sort of uphill and speed would take over, so they probably wouldn’t get there if you did it as a line. Tyson, who built these fences for me, has been having sleepless nights over the tables, because he thinks they’re huge – but I think it’s great! I love big fences like that down a hill, and what I really want to do is stand on the landing side of the second table just to get a photograph of the expression on the riders’ faces, because normally they’ll go with their mouths wide open and their eyes popping!”
Ian Stark, once again.
Fence 17.
After that, there’s a proper galloping stretch to get that rhythm going again and give those gutsy horses a big pat, before a single fence at 17 that somehow looks — dare we say it? — quite small.
“It’s maximum height and spread for the level, but it looks like a training fence, and the reason for it is it’s so wide,” says Ian. “Next year I’m planning to take a chainsaw to it and make it two fences, and then it’ll look taller and be a double.”
Fence 18ab.
The uninfluential gates of last year make a return, this time without a floral groundline.
“They’re very upright timber chase fences, but the ground is rising up to these fences, and I don’t think they need the groundline, so I’ve removed the plant pots and got approval from the ground jury and the technical delegate,” says Ian, before adding, reflectively: “Maybe I’ve been a bit mean!”
Fence 19.
Fence 19 is another single fence, which is a galloping jump that’ll still require plenty of respect, because this sucker is big.
Fence 20.
Then, it’s a left-handed turn to another water, though this time, they won’t need to actually enter the pond at all. The direct route here is two imposing ditch corners at 20 and 21, though there’s a pair of owl holes on a longer line if riders want to mix and match.
“The corners are pretty huge, and we’ve got seven truckloads of water going in there. What I wanted was all the dirt under the corner to be covered by water – I don’t think I’m very popular with the boys, having to find all that water,” says Ian. “Then there’s the option of the owl holes, and Doug Payne said to me, ‘thank God we don’t have to jump them’ – he’s so tall he thinks he’ll decapitate himself on them!”
Fence 21.
This leads onto one of the flattest bits of the course: “the flat bit of ground here lets the horses recover before the big water,” says Ian.
Fence 22.
On their way to that big water, they’ve got another single fence to jump, which will just add a bit of confidence and fun to the equation before another mentally challenging task.
Fence 23AB, with 24ABC visible on the left-hand side.
And what a task it is! The main water complex has been turned around this year, and the famous crab jump in has been moved out from the bank, which will require a wider jump in — and this time, they land on a dry ramp before cantering into the water, swinging a left, jumping a bank up to a log on a bounce distance at 24AB and then finding a seriously accurate line to a steeply angled brush at 24C. What makes the crab at 23AB so imposing is that you can’t see it until the last couple of strides: the approach up to this water is a steep, short hill, and two strides out, its terrifying face appears with the noise and distraction of the VIP tent behind it on the other side of the water.
“The approach means they can’t see what they’re jumping until they run up that ramp, and then they have two strides to assess it,” says Ian. “It’s a big drop and then they’re looking into the MARS sponsors tent, so there’s a lot to see. It’s at nine and a half minutes, so it’s late for a big water – but I hope that having a lot to look at will sharpen them up again. I put a ramp in the water because it was way over a maximum drop, and it doesn’t worry me that they’ll land on the dry.”
Fence 24ab.
The line from the hanging log at 24B to 24C is a tight three, and it’s a wide-open door for horses to run out to the right if the riders aren’t on it — but the long route through this water is so long that those who are in close contention will need to take the risk if they want to stay at the business end of the leaderboard. And with just over 12 penalties separating the entire leaderboard? That’s an opportunity for just about everyone.
“They’re not going to win prizes if they go the long way, but hopefully at this stage on the course if horses are getting a little fatigued, then their riders can think and go the long way and help get their horses home.”
Fence 25.
Ian’s given them a downhill run from the water, which helps tired horses bowl along without taxing them too much. There’s some set-up to be done for fence 25, which is a pseudo-Vicarage Vee, but he’s made the approach totally obvious: a line of trees puts horses right where they need to be, which is on the small, straight bit of revetting on the ditch lip.
“This was a corner last year, and I’ve taken the back rail off because I feel like this is four fences from home, and the corner was too big a question this late on course,” says Ian, who has fitted the fence with sensitive yellow MIMclips. “I’ve used trees to put the horses on the line – they’ve got to stay straight, but I’ve taken a lot of the guesswork out. It’s up to them to get the right striding, but the line is there. I do think we’ll get the odd run-out, but if we do, there’s a long route over a trakehner for them.”
Fence 26ab.
The final combination on the course is the striking rollercoaster combination at 26ABCD, and this year, the first element has been pushed closer to the big drop at the B element. Then there’s a pair of houses at 26d and 27 on a pretty stiff angle, which gives riders a choice in terms of their line.
“I’m hoping that they’ll jump off on the right side as they’re approaching the drop and turn to the first one ,and then turn in the air to the second one,” says Ian. “If they try and go on a straighter line [between the houses] I think it’s quite a big ask, but people have to decide what their horses are capable of and what they see in their own eye and from their own point of view.”
The view from 26c to 26d.
Here’s another look at that line from the drop, which Ian hopes to see riders jump on the right hand side so they can get a direct shot to the first of the houses.
Fence 27.
And, for good measure, a look at the houses from the landing side, again using a #SallyForScale. They’re not the biggest fences on course by a long stretch, but this is still enough of a question — but once again, there’s a slower, less intense route for those who just want to nurse their horses home.
Fence 28.
There’s a big old table to jump at the penultimate question, but this single fence is on a downhill, which Ian hopes will give horses some engine back as they coast down.
“It’s not maximum spread and it’s got a lovely 45 degree front on it, and it’s downhill a bit on the approach so that if they are getting a bit tired, they can get a bit of energy back on the downhill,” says Ian. “Then the riders can ride the fence before they come back into the middle field.”
Fence 29.
Once they’ve made it back into the middle field, they’ll see every rider’s favourite fence: the final one.
“It’s a very bright, cheerful last fence, because I want the horses to see it and pay attention,” says Ian. “Finishing in the middle field means they then go on to the quiet back corner for the vet box, and then they can just walk back through the trees to the stables.”
Honestly, that’s the only bit we’d be happy to volunteer ourselves for.
As it turns out, Ian was the T-rex all along.
CCI5* cross-country kicks off from 2 p.m. Eastern time (7 p.m. BST/11.00 a.m. Pacific). You can check out what the competitors themselves think of the course here — and keep it locked on EN for all the news, views, and updates you need. Go Eventing!
Tim Price pilots the ‘unknown’ Coup de Coeur Dudevin to a close second place. Photo by Tilly Berendt.
Yesterday’s MARS Maryland CCI5* leaders, Woods Baughman and C’est La Vie 135, had arguably the worst possible conditions to deal with for dressage, battling through driving sheets of rain that were so thick you could scarcely spot them in the ring — but that grit and toughness that characterises event riders won out, and even with the perfect conditions today, nobody could usurp their leaderboard-topping 27.2.
But several riders in today’s set of 12 gave it a good go — and the newly-minted World Number One Tim Price, who sits second overnight on a 27.4 with five-star debutant Coup de Coeur Dudevin, was quick to acknowledge his luck in missing the deluge.
“I felt so sorry for Woods yesterday, because it wasn’t just the heavy rain, but the wet surface, too — but in a way, it makes the determination of the rider come out, and you really kick on,” he muses. “But I was really pleased to have sunshine today — not least for my groom, Kerryn Edmans, because she puts so much work into making [my horse] gleam, and it was nice that she could show that off.”
This is just Tim’s third international outing with the ten-year-old Selle Français (Top Gun Semilly x Tiebreak Combehory, by LePrince des Bois), and only the horse’s third-ever long-format competition — and so, although this is essentially a fact-finding mission, it’s one that’s intended to act as a foundation for big things to come.
“He’s a really talented horse, and I really believe in him as a proper five-star horse for the Badmintons and Burghleys, and now for Fair Hill, which I’d put in the same category as those other famous ones,” says Tim. “That’s why he’s here — you know, he’s inexperienced, but he’s here to get some education on the job, and all I want from him in that department is to be relaxed and to show himself in the true light of where he’s working. And that’s what he is: he has a few mistakes, and he’s a bit unestablished, and a bit comes and goes, but the quality underneath it all and the relaxation is what makes me very happy with him.”
Tim Price and Coup de Coeur Dudevin. Photo by Tilly Berendt.
Tim rides the gelding for breeder Jean-Louis Stauffer, who originally sent the horse to Swiss talent Robin Godel for his early production and then placed him with Australia’s Chris Burton, with whom he competed up to CCI3*-L and finished seventh in both the Six- and Seven-Year-Old World Championships.
“Chris subsequently stopped eventing and went showjumping, and that’s about the time the horse came into our stables. Jonelle started with the horse last year, but he’s just got so much power that she found it quite difficult. She’s small, so she got thrown about a bit and just didn’t feel totally at home with him, so she — reluctantly! — suggested he came my way, because she always knew he was going to be a proper horse for the job. It was quite difficult for her to offer him up to me!”
The talent he possesses is undeniable, and his results with Tim have been exciting, including a second place finish in his sole CCI4*-L run at Millstreet and 12th in a huge, competitive field at Haras du Pin CCIO4*-S in August — but even so, Tim acknowledges that tomorrow’s trip is something of an unknown.
“I’m kind of taking a leap of faith, because he’s so short on experience — but what he has done, he’s done extremely well,” he says. “He loves a big fence, and he does it all with a smile on his face, so it’s my job to give him a good experience all the way around the course and maintain that enjoyment at this level.”
Allie Knowles makes it happen with Morswood. Photo by Tilly Berendt.
Allie Knowles and the former Piggy March and Susie Berry ride Morswood, with whom she finished eleventh here last year, stepped into third place overnight in fine style, putting a 28.8 on the board — a score that isn’t just a personal best for the gelding, it’s also an all-time five-star PB for Allie herself.
“That feels great,” says Allie with a big smile. “We’ve definitely been working towards that. He’s always had it in him, but he’s a much stronger horse this year. Last year was his first year at the five-star level, and he did a great performance, but this year he’s just more mature and stronger in the hind end, stronger in the back, and his self-carriage is certainly more than it was before. You know that kind of test is in there, and then you have to sort of hope that it comes out at the right moment.”
Allie Knowles celebrates with her team and supporters after her test. Photo by Tilly Berendt.
Katherine O’Brien’s fourteen-year-old Irish Sport Horse (Ricardo x Princess in Arms, by Present Arms) has been a part of Allie’s string since early 2018, and in that time, he’s firmly established himself as the biggest personality in her barn.
“He is a straight pony, through and through,” she laughs. “He’s a ginger pony; an Irish puppy dog. He’s a nuisance all the time, but in the best way! He’ll follow us around like a dog; he’ll try to escape his stall — I came out of the ring and he was all excited, but the second we hit the first blade of grass, his head was on the ground and he was ready to eat! He’s all heart and personality, but he is funny. He’s gentle with [my daughter] Addy but fierce on cross-country — he’s just a good pony.”
One of the things that makes their partnership tick so well is that Allie and Morswood’s respective strengths complement one another to a tee.
“He enjoys every minute of [cross-country] all the time, and he’d prefer to do that every day, so he’s a great fit for me,” says Allie. “I wouldn’t be the most aggressive cross-country rider — I love dressage, and I love working on showjumping, so to have a horse like him complements my riding really well. So for the last couple of years, it’s been a steady progression of confidence and strength on his part and physical strength and confidence for me on cross-country. At this stage, we’re a very close partnership, so I have complete faith in him and I think he has complete faith in me. It makes every event very fun and something to look forward to.”
Doug Payne and Quantum Leap make a, well, quantum leap in first-phase performance. Photo by Tilly Berendt.
Yesterday’s second, third, and fourth-placed competitors, Astier Nicolas and Babylon de Gamma, Liz Halliday-Sharp and Cooley Quicksilver, and Tamie Smith and Danito, now sit fourth, fifth, and sixth respectively going into cross-country, while seventh place goes to Doug Payne and Quantum Leap, who delivered a sparkling 29.5.
Though the eleven-year-old German Sport Horse (Quite Capitol x Report to Sloopy, by Corporate Report) certainly isn’t short on experience, with three five-star completions and two placings to his name already, he’s historically struggled with this phase, and this is only the second time in his 20 FEI runs that he’s broken into the twenties. But his sudden uptick in performance on the flat is no accident: instead, it comes down to some savvy schooling from Doug, who has minimised his eventing outings and maximised his exposure to, well, a little bit of productive chaos.
“He didn’t need to go to that many events, but we’re taking him to all the bigger environments we can, and so he comes along jumping with us a lot,” says Doug. “We’ll jump a couple of days that week, and through that, I’ll try to find the most chaotic corner possible and go flat him there! So he’s just turned the corner where he’s gotten strong enough that he can hold it, and when he can do that, he’s super comfortable. The thing that makes him the most uncomfortable and the most tense is when he struggles to rise to the expectation. He’s an overachiever, so he tries too much, almost.”
The gelding’s newfound confidence in this phase was certainly tested, though, by a bit of a false start to their test, which saw them enter at A and then promptly exit again after a slight mishap from the hard-working volunteers in the ring.
“They opened the wrong gate, so I wasn’t on the centreline,” laughs Doug. “I was like, ‘that’s a little off, but whatever!’ and then all of a sudden they’re ringing the bell again. I’m like, ‘okay, I guess we’re starting over!’ The poor little girl, though, was almost in tears — but it’s fine, stuff happens all the time!”
Hannah Sue Hollberg’s Harbour Pilot looks at his best in his swansong test. Photo by Tilly Berendt.
It’s a tightly-packed leaderboard heading into the pivotal phase, and equal eighth-placed Hannah Sue Hollberg and her stalwart partner Harbour Pilot sit just three-tenths of a penalty behind Doug on their score of 29.8.
“He was awesome — I was really happy with him,” says Hannah Sue. “I was struggling with him in the last few weeks with the ridiculous trot work movements where you have to go sideways and change directions and stuff, because he gets kind of scrambly with his legs. So I asked David to help me this afternoon and he gave me some good pointers, and it really paid off in the ring.”
“I thought it was pretty good — I mean, the canter work was excellent, and the trot work was pretty good. It was just the halt — he didn’t really want to stand still, but otherwise, it was good!”
“Show him the love!” Hannah Sue interacts with her loud and enthusiastic fanbase in Maryland’s capacious grandstand. Photo by Tilly Berendt.
At nineteen, ‘William’ is the elder statesman of the Maryland field in a year that has seen high-profile horses of this age thrive on the world stage — and for Hannah Sue, that means she can ride for every mark in the ring.
“He feels the exact same, but a little bit quieter,” she says. “Sometimes he can still kind of freak out, but he’s more reliable, I would say, than he was when he was younger!”
Getting him this far in his career, and still thriving, has been all about consistency — and a horse-first approach, above all.
“I’ve always put him first. If the footing isn’t great, I wouldn’t run him. I love him, so I always took care of him — if something didn’t feel right, I wouldn’t push him. I’ve maintained him the same all the way through.”
All good things must come to an end, though, and as Hannah Sue and William finished their test, it was to one of the biggest cheers of the day from a crowd of fans who were keen to bid him adieu with the send-off he deserves.
“This is going to be his last run, and it’s really crazy, because I never really thought about it ending until now — and now I’m like, ‘oh my gosh, this is horrible!’,” says Hannah Sue. “But I’m so happy to make this decision ahead of time, rather than something horrible happening. It’s special to be able to take care of him his whole career and do the right thing for him — he’s Capitol HIM’s best friend and field mate, so he’s just going to hang out with me. He can go retire at Ms Mars’s beautiful farm in Virginia, but I’m not quite ready for that yet!”
Buck Davidson and Carlevo wrap up the dressage and step into the top ten. Photo by Tilly Berendt.
Sitting pretty alongside them in equal eighth is Buck Davidson, whose second ride of the week, Carlevo, also posted a 29.8 to best stablemate Sorocaima, seventeenth on 35.7. That 29.8 puts them in a very competitive position, just 2.6 penalties off the lead, but sees them hit a mark that’s not quite on the money of their six-run average of 27.
“He’s always good, but it felt like the ground got really tacky in there,” says Buck. “It felt different from the warm-up, and that made it feel like it was hard work. It just felt like the second half of the medium trot, it was like he was pulling himself out of the mud, and it didn’t feel that way in the warm-up. But whatever, it is what it is — that’s the sport! He did the test he always does, and he’s always good; we’ve just got a lot of work to do tomorrow.”
Oliver Townend and As Is take tenth place in the first phase. Photo by Tilly Berendt.
Oliver Townend rounds out the top ten with the five-star debutant As Is, who scored 29.9 in his first five-star test. The Spanish-bred eleven-year-old (Meneusekal x Paraca, by Lacros) joined his string this season, having been previously produced by Andrew Nicholson.
“He’s obviously a very new horse to me, and we’re working on the progression, but the brain is beautiful,” says Oliver, who returns to Maryland after finishing second in the inaugural running of the event with Cooley Master Class. “He goes in and he does his job, and we’re working on getting him stronger and a little bit more flash, but that’ll come. Next year, he’ll be in the top three after dressage.”
As Is joins the likes of Swallow Springs and Cillnabradden Evo as horses that Oliver has inherited from his longtime friend and gone on to compete at the top level with.
“I’ve ridden plenty that have come from Andrew,” he says. “He always produces horses to be professional, and it’s a real pleasure to get on a proper professional’s horse. I’m not particularly a fan of getting on horses that have been produced to a high level by amateurs, because the buttons are all over the place — but you know that with Andrew’s horses, whether you’re doing the trot-up or the dressage or whatever, they’re professionals at it, and they’ve been treated that way since they were four years old. It makes my job a lot easier.”
Coming back to Maryland, Oliver says, was an easy decision after his experience last year, even with the unknown quantity that is a five-star first-time.
“It’s an amazing event, and the prize money in Pau wasn’t good enough,” he says. “We came here last year and the people are fantastic; the organisers are great; the Ian Stark course was very special; and the American people are lovely to ride in front of. I’d be in America every week if there was a five-star every week.”
Now it’s time for everyone’s focus to shift to Ian Stark’s big, bold, tough cross-country challenge tomorrow, which will get underway from 2pm Eastern (7.00 p.m. BST/11.00 a.m. West Coast) tomorrow. You can find full 5* ride times here. We’ll be bringing you a full course preview, plus riders’ reactions to the new-look, seriously beefed up track — but until then, as always, Go Eventing!
The top ten at the culmination of dressage in the MARS Maryland CCI5*.
It’s been a short and sweet day at the MARS Maryland 5 Star — and at the very end of the day, in the most torrential weather of the day, we got ourselves an overnight leader in Woods Baughman and C’est La Vie 135. You can read all about it in Sally’s full report this evening, but for now, whet your whistle with this very soggy replay of the test that set the standard. Woods, we salute you!
Getting to a CCI5* is an extraordinary accomplishment, and one that many riders will spend a lifetime working towards. Tens of thousands of hours; blood, sweat, tears; moments spent lying in the arena dirt wondering what on earth the point of it is — all of that leads here, to the first horse inspection at one of the biggest competitions in the world, and the validation that you did the right things, pushed through the tough times, and gained entry into the most elite club of all. If you trotted up a horse at the MARS Maryland 5 Star yesterday, know this: you’ve made it. But also know this: I am now going to make fun of you, with love and admiration. Keep on scrolling to meet this year’s Golden Chinch Award winners at the penultimate five-star of the year.
The Golden Chinch for the Rider Most Likely to Run a FinDom Empire
Hannah Sue Hollberg and Harbour Pilot. Photo by Tilly Berendt.
EN boss lady Sally Spickard and I sat out by our little fire pit at our Delaware AirBNB last night, sharing a cigarette and some crab fries (no, not a euphemism) and winding down after a long course walk at Maryland.
“I have a friend,” she told me, pausing to take a long, luxurious drag, “who’s a financial dominatrix.”
I looked at her, my interest piqued.
“She verbally abuses men, sends them a photo of her feet, and then gets a thousand bucks from them,” she explained.
Now, Hannah Sue Hollberg definitely isn’t a financial dominatrix, because who actually has time for taking feet pics when you have a load of horses to ride every day and a very, very nice new husband to hang out with, too? But something about this eye-catching, body-skimming head-to-toe leather outfit tells me she could if she wanted to, and she’d be making a heck of a lot more than a thousand bucks doing so, as well. It’s all a bit Velvet Underground — shiny, shiny boots of leather; whiplash girl child, and all that — honestly? I’m here for it.
The Golden Chinch for When You’ve Got a Trot-Up at 1, But You Need to Wrangle Those Dogeys at 3
Woods Baughman and C’est La Vie 135. Photo by Tilly Berendt.
I’ve met Woods Baughman exactly once before this week, and that was in the Burghley mixed zone, where everyone suddenly went really silly and quite odd when it came time to interview him, mostly because he is, let’s be real, very good-looking. He is also a brave, brave boy when it comes to footwear choices. I almost didn’t clock these cowboy clodhoppers as he line-danced his way down the trot-strip, because in my head, I’d already written him off as yet another man in a staid suit. Snore, thought I. More fool me! Woods Baughman is here to put a boot in yer ass, ‘cuz it’s the American way, or something like that, anyway, and he’s got a handy-dandy hoof pick on his belt, too, because what are cowboys if not practical chaps who are ready for just about anything? I, for one, hope that the suit and cowboy boot combo takes over from the regrettable suit and baseball cap situation that has plagued US eventing for far too long. Woods, if you’re reading this, I’ll be wearing my own, very silver, cowboy boots to the final horse inspection — I’ll meet you there for a hoedown. Again, I cannot stress enough that this is not a euphemism.
I’ve been brushing up on some cowboy lingo in preparation, which has been An Experience in and of itself, and so, Woods, let me offer you some sage advice: you’ll never feel more above snakes than you do while competing at a five-star. It can be a hog-killin’ time, or it can be a bit of a bad box, but no matter which hand you’re dealt, don’t be a yellow belly. Try not to get busted off, definitely avoid chewing gravel, and remember that you’re better than a lick and a promise. If you’re angry at me for victimising you in my jog awards, you can crawl my hump at five p.m. today. Ooo-er.
The Golden Chinch for Being the Nicest Boy in Peaky Blinders
Will Coleman and Dondante. Photo by Tilly Berendt.
Peaky Blinders fever has swept the eventing world, which always makes me laugh, because event riders — as tough and ballsy and undeniably cool as they are — are about as far from Brummy gangsters as you could possibly get. They enjoy the finer things in life, like, um, dressage (although ‘enjoy’ might be a strong word for most) and cocktail parties. I don’t think Will Coleman has ever ordered anyone to be brutally murdered, although I’m willing to concede that I don’t know everything about everyone and I could be totally wrong there. The flat cap tells me that he’d like to think he has a touch of the crime boss in him, but I think what we’ve got here is a walk-on extra role, in which a smiley, sunny Will drives his milk cart up to the Blinders’ den of iniquity and kindly offers them the choice between full, semi-skim, and gold top. It’s important to ensure that one’s calcium levels are tip-top before a long, hard day of doing naughty things. And you know what? Will’s Got Milk? campaign is working on me. Pour me a tall one, chap.
The Golden Chinch for Hair That’s Booking a Ticket to That Blink-182 Reunion Tour
Jennie Brannigan and FE Lifestyle. Photo by Tilly Berendt.
If there’s one thing you need to know about me, it’s this: I am a die-hard Josie and the Pussycatsapologist. I truly believe that the 2001 Rachael Leigh Cook-led ensemble piece is a work of fine art; perhaps one of the greatest film ventures of all time, like Casablanca or Gone With The Wind. This is a hill I will die on, very happily. Josie and the Pussycats awareness is, I think, the mission I was put on this earth to fulfil. And in the year of our lord 2022, I do believe that Jennie B has joined my cause.
First, there was her outfit at Kentucky this spring, which might have been my favourite trot-up outfit of all time. Like many riders, she came out in head to toe Holland Cooper, but instead of wearing the British brand in the Kate Middleton way, she punked it up, pairing a cropped tartan blazer with a pair of skin-tight leather trousers and a heeled ankle boot, looking as though she was ready to pick up a swoopy-fringed boy in the back of a Hot Topic and then maybe snog him in a mosh pit or something. Today, she went full Punk Rock Prom Queen, pairing a Sunday school skirt and scarf combo with a very tarty boot and stocking situation. I cannot explain to you how intensely I intend ‘very tarty’ to be a compliment.
The piece de resistance? That newly pink mane of hair, which says “look, I could do things your way. I could be the president of the National Honour Society. I could sell bon-bons for French Club in my free period. Or — and just bear with me for a moment here — I could start a thrash band with a name like ‘The Riotous Womb-Sluts’ and I could also, maybe, at a push, kick your ass.”
The Golden Chinch for Chaotic Sock Abandonment
Tim Price and Coup de Coeur Dudevin. Photo by Tilly Berendt.
New Zealand’s Tim Price can do what he likes, really, because he’s the World Number one, and I’m pretty sure that grants you diplomatic immunity from internet piss-takes. HOWEVER. He’s been a very, very rogue boy here, and has brought forward a look that I am never quite sure about. That look? A sockless loafer situation; very trendy, admittedly, among the slim-trouser-and-quaffed-hair chaps of the UK scene, but one that always, regrettably, makes me think a bit too much about the practical logistics of the thing. I just know it smells extraordinary in those loafers, unless, of course, Tim is hiding a secret sock in there. Then, of course, I have to take a moment to picture Tim wandering around in those cheeky lil’ toe condoms, and I’m honestly not sure which option makes me feel more uncomfortable. Perhaps Tim, too, is shilling feet pics on the side. Perhaps EN just started the rumour of the century. Perhaps.
The Golden Chinch for Egregious Flirtation with the Colour Wheel
Astier Nicolas and Babylon de Gamma. Photo by Tilly Berendt.
Look, there’s a lot of blues going on here. A real spectrum of blues. The problem is that none of them are even in the same family. We’ve got a periwinkle trouser, an aqua windowpane, a baby blue shirt, and a Dennis the Menace tie that harks back to the days when the cool thing to do was either have your school-issued tie six inches too long or twelve inches too short. It’s a chaotic ensemble, and one that only a Frenchman who’s posed for Givenchy could pull off. Astier allez-ed les bleus, for sure, but perhaps he allez-ed les bleus too close to the sun.
The Golden Chinch For Refusing to Fetch the Milk, MOM
Doug Payne and Quantum Leap. Photo by Tilly Berendt.
Doug Payne is a sharp dressed man, don’t get me wrong. But something about his whole vibe here tells me that his mom just got home from the local Piggly Wiggly and shouted up to his bedroom that she needs some help bringing the groceries in, right as Doug was about to hit an all-time kill streak in a fierce COD blast-off. Last time he fobbed her off she took his X-Box privileges away, so he’s going to do it this time, but he’s also going to make sure she knows just how unhappy he is about it. Don’t worry, Doug. She got you a can of Monster for your troubles, and that sweet, sweet rage nectar will ease your pain and fire you up for even more wanton machine gunning. Go pwn those noobz. Pwn them hard.
The Golden Chinch for Actually Just Legitimately Nailing the Brief
Liz Halliday-Sharp and Cooley Quicksilver. Photo by Tilly Berendt.
I know I’m here with one mission, and that is to gently lampoon, but truly, I have nothing funny to say about Liz Halliday-Sharp’s smart, flattering, flared jumpsuit. It’s giving Studio 54, but on one of the rare nights in which Bianca Jagger didn’t ride in naked on a horse. Liz consistently rocks some great looks for trot-ups, but this one wins the prize for her best yet, and the look of the week here at Maryland. Go forth and conquer, LHS.
Every course designer has a different set of priorities and a different modus operandi — and understanding your designer is key to unpacking what it is they’re looking for from your round. Lucinda Green explains this concept, and teaches you how to walk like a pro, in the latest instalment of her XC Academy.
Supplements you can count on from Kentucky Performance Products.
When it comes to keeping your horse happy and healthy, you can depend on your friends at Kentucky Performance Products (KPP). Our company is owned and operated by horse people just like you. That means we’re out in the barn every day dealing with the same challenges you are. We’re committed to producing the best nutrition supplements possible because our horses use them too!
The nominations for this year’s FEI Awards are live, and we’re delighted to see two members of the eventing family in contention! Kerryn Edmans, groom to Tim and Jonelle Price, is up for the Cavalor Best Groom Prize, while 20-year-old British 5* rider Alice Casburn is nominated for the Longines Rising Star prize. Give them your vote here!
National Holiday: It’s Indigenous Peoples’ Day. Read more about how Native Americans have been intertwined with horses here.
US Weekend Action:
Morven Park Fall International CCI4*-L (Leesburg, VA): [Website] [Results]
There’s a name you might not recognise on the Maryland 5 Star entry list — that of New Zealand’s Hayley Frielick. But this girl’s got a serious story, and once you read it, you’ll definitely be cheering her on as she tackles the event with her horse, Dunedin Black Watch. [Meet her here]
Short girls, unite! It often feels like the horse world has been wholly designed to cater to long-legged ladies, and to be fair, as a 5’7 gal, I’ve definitely benefited from that. But if you’re short of leg, you deserve to have breeches that fit without bunching, too. (Although you do get a more comfortable ride on planes, so you win there). [An ode to the shorties]
If you’re a Fairfax and Favor fan, you may have wondered where the iconic boots came from. The answer? Two chaps in their 20s, who had a long-time friendship, a deep appreciation for all things country, and a failed bouncy castle company idea behind them. [From zero to heroes]
And finally, after watching Alyssa Phillips make her team debut at Boekelo, it’s time to get to know the girl behind the performances. At just 25 years old, she’s living the dream with her three beautiful horses and a longtime training partnership with Jennie Brannigan. [Chasing the dream]
Want to follow a rider on his way to the top, and get plenty of robust motivation along the way? Then you need to follow Italy’s Pietro Grandis, who recently left his longtime role as Michael Jung’s stable jockey to pursue his goals.
Morning Viewing:
How incredible is this archive footage of the US Olympic team in training for the 1948 Olympics?
And just like that, another Boekelo was over — but not without a generous helping of drama right down to the last seconds of the competition.
Just 14 of the 53 starters would deliver clears inside the time on Kris Van Gelder‘s track, and so tightly packed was the leaderboard that a rail — or a clear — would send competitors tumbling down or shooting up the leaderboard. And so when Tim Price delivered the goods — and one of eight FODs in the class — with his 2019 Seven-Year-Old World Champion Happy Boy, he was delighted — but he wasn’t thinking much further than that he’d secured himself second place. When two-phase leader Laura Collett took a late rail with Dacapo, then, it didn’t quite hit him what had happened.
“It’s not sinking in very quick,” laughs Tim, who refers to the ten-year-old as the literal and figurative dark horse of his yard. “I focused so much on jumping a good clean round, and I put the rest to one side — and Laura jumps clear round after clear round in her career on any given horse, and Dacapo is a very good jumper. So I just thought, ‘well, I’m very happy to be on the podium!’ I never thought I’d win it, but he’s a great little horse — he’s the consummate all-rounder for eventing. He’s just really nifty; he comes out and does his best in each phase.”
Tim Price clears the last to an enormous roar from the packed house of spectators. Photo by Tilly Berendt.
The win comes just two days after the recent double bronze medallist was announced as the World Number One — followed by his wife, Jonelle, in second.
“It’s unbelievable, isn’t it? I’m such a slow starter in the year; I fumble and muck it up for half the year,” he muses. “It’s a bit like me in the mornings, really — it’s like a stretch into the year. I need until about 1pm to get going! But that was really cool, and I’m so lucky at the moment. I’ve got some nice horses, and there’s so much hard work that goes on behind the scenes. You’re training away for years and years, and I think that’s what’s really on display. It might look from the outside like we just step on and step off week after week, but like this guy, I’ve had him since he was four, and you just chip away and try to make the right decisions along the way and place them well. On days like this, you feel like you’re reaping the benefits of a lot of hard work and planning.”
Tim Price and Happy Boy celebrate a red letter week for the Price clan. Photo by Tilly Berendt.
Tim and Jonelle, who came to the UK in the early 2000s with very little to their name but a dream and a heaping helping of tenacity, have pushed through their fair share of tough times and tricky competitions — but self-belief, he says, is the key for young riders hoping to follow in their footsteps.
“Don’t think too much about the work ahead — just keep your head down and carry on quietly, and stay focused on what you want to do in the sport,” he says. “I was talking to a young rider earlier, asking me a question like that, and I think you’ve got to tell the people around you that your ambition is to get to the top. You’re not really trying to sell horses; you’re not really trying to duck and dive — but you might have to to get there. Let it be known, and the more you put that around yourself, the more it can become reality one day.”
One of the most admirable things about the Price family is the diversity of their time: rather than remaining tunnel-visioned on riding at every moment of the day, they make time for the other things that make life great, including family, holidays, and taking the time to explore the many places they travel to while competing. And that, too, is crucial to avoiding burnout, says Tim.
“You’ll get pretty floored after a bad competition, so you’ve got to build yourself up again and again. You just get good at refining the timescale to do that — two or three days and then you get going again. But really, you’ve got to live a healthy life; a fairly well-rounded life. We’re not pure athletes; to be honest, we can live a little with our lifestyles and things, and you’ve got to keep that healthy balance so you can bounce back and get enthusiastic about what’s around the corner. I think that’s what the real key is: that we love it so much that we can let that filter in very quickly.”
Amen to that, Mr. Price.
Tom McEwen takes second — or ‘equal first’ — with new ride JL Dublin. Photo by Tilly Berendt.
“I’m going to call that ‘equal first’,” jokes Tom McEwen, who finished in second place — though on the same score as the winners — with new ride JL Dublin in their first international run together. They lost out on the tiebreak by hundredths of a second after finishing yesterday’s cross-country in 10:06 — a second faster, but a second further from the 10:10 optimum time, than Tim and Happy Boy.
“He was amazing, but obviously I was getting a bit nervous on the time yesterday,” he says. “I had every opportunity, but the horse was epic.”
For Tom, there was the added weight of a different kind of pressure this week. JL Dublin is best known for his partnership with Nicola Wilson, with whom he won last year’s European Championships — among a spate of other major wins — and while Tom is struck by his good fortune at getting to deputise for her after her accident at Badminton this year, he’s eminently conscious that in happier circumstances, there would be another rider in the irons for today’s prizegiving.
“It all comes down to Nic,” he says. “She produced him, and to come here on two intermediate runs and come second — that’s all down to her, and actually, if she’d been on him, he’d have flown around and won quite comfortably. He’s phenomenal, and it’s all thanks to her and all the hard work she’s done for years and years with him. So I can only say thank you: thank you to her, and thank you to her owners for trusting me with such an incredible horse.”
Tom McEwen and JL Dublin. Photo by Tilly Berendt.
Before heading out on course yesterday, ordinarily icy-veined Tom was nervous — after all, he’d had very few runs with the horse and only a couple of months to get to know him.
“The first three fences, I was gauging where I was at, because we’ve only done two OIs,” he says. “I was a bit nervous in the morning, but as soon as I set off, I was like, ‘no, we didn’t need to anything more than those’. He was phenomenal. At the tricky combinations he flew; I had to add at the two overs, so I made sure we balanced to the water, but to be honest, we went around in a hand canter, which is why I found getting closer to the time so difficult. He was coming out of the main arena at the end of the course and I was trying to slow him down, but all he wanted to do was carry on galloping. He’s a machine, and he’s world class — there’s not many like him. Even though we came here to do well, at the same time it was very much a learning experience, so to come out like this is fantastic.”
Laura Collett and Dacapo slip to third after a frustrating late rail. Photo by Tilly Berendt.
“If you’d said we’d be third coming here, we’d all have been delighted, but obviously it’s a bit gutting dropping from first to third,” says Laura Collett, whose late rail at the tenth fence with Dacapo cost her the lead she’d held on 21.9 through the first two phases. But the week has still been a victory, in a way, for the mercurial gelding, who tends to either place or push himself right down to the bottom end of the pack with occasional naughty moments across the country. Like stablemate London 52, whose career turning point came after his confidence-boosting win here in 2019, the week has looked to be a very positive one for the 13-year-old gelding, with whom Laura has simply focused on enjoying four-star outings this year in a bid to sustain his focus and push him toward the path of least resistance. In that respect? It’s been mission very much accomplished.
“He’s had a great time and performed brilliantly,” says Laura. “He hasn’t had a wobble all year, and he’s had a bit of a funny prep coming here — he’s run in intermediates, and he’s been to Burghley and done a demo there, and things like that. He obviously just likes to have a bit of change, and the main thing is that he was brilliant on the cross-country. Any horse can have a fence down, and unfortunately, he had one today, but it doesn’t take away from how good he’s been this week.”
World Champion Yasmin Ingham closes the book on a super week with Rehy DJ after a tricky start. Photo by Tilly Berendt.
Newly-crowned World Champion Yasmin Ingham had another super week, this time with the sweet, stalwart Rehy DJ, who is also owned by Banzai du Loir’s owners Sue Davies and Janette Chinn. He’s performed in his usual, reliable way despite an unfortunate incident after the first horse inspection, in which a water bowser was turned on as he walked by and he got loose, slipped, and sustained a superficial graze, which resulted in his withdrawal from the British Nations Cup team to allow an extra day of observation. That call paid off, and he’s looked at his best since, climbing from first-phase ninth place after finishing on his dressage score of 28.7.
“It’s gone from not so good to really, really good, so I’m very happy,” says Yasmin. “It wasn’t the best start to the week with our little incident, but his graze has healed up miraculously quickly thanks to the help of [team GB vet] Liz Brown and [groom] Allison and all the team here. He’s had the best of care and attention, and he’s feeling fantastic. He jumped his socks off today, and he really deserved the clear round — he tried so hard.”
‘Piglet’ is becoming something of a Mr Consistency in Yasmin’s string, and so consistency is the watchword in how she prepares him, too.
“We know how he works now, and we know what to do in the warm-up so we can get him feeling his best for the showjumping, so we stuck to our usual routine and he delivered. I’m very proud of him.”
For 25-year-old Yasmin, it’s a slightly surreal feeling to be announced into the ring as the World Champion every time she performs — but she deals with the pressure in her usual, sunny way.
“It’s a little reminder every time like, ‘oh yeah, that happened!’ But then I’m like, ‘don’t tell everyone before I jump, though, because it might go really badly!'” she laughs. “
Liz Halliday-Sharp proves she has an Olympic talent in the excellent Miks Master C. Photo by Tilly Berendt.
Though Liz Halliday-Sharp is still getting to know her ride of just five months, Miks Master C — “I’ve tried him in new bits for all three phases for the first time this week,” she laughs — she knew from the word ‘go’ that he was a talent of huge proportions, and he certainly proved that in spades this week. The pair initially sat in sixth place after an expressive test for 26.2, which looked expressive and fluid despite the gelding’s current tendency towards a bit too much power, and dropped down to eighth after that strength meant that Liz added 3.2 time penalties while setting up for the fences. But today, all the pieces came together, and the very fresh US-bred ten-year-old, who she rides for Ocala Horse Properties and Debbie Palmer, produced an easy clear inside the time to take fifth place.
“He’s such a fabulous horse, and we’re still figuring stuff out about him — like, today’s the first day I’ve ever jumped him in that bit in the ring in my life,” says Liz. “He was a bit strong with me in my last run, and I think he fought even harder on the last day, so I couldn’t be happier to jump double clear and finish in the 20s with him in our first long format together after just five months.”
Today was a major test for the gelding, and Liz called in the big guns to help her get the job done in training for the final day.
“I’ve kind of had him piss off with me in the ring before, so I was so thrilled with how he just fought for me the whole way. I’ve had a lot of help from Peter Wylde and Erik Duvander, and that’s been really great. I think we’re on the right path forward with him, and ready to step him up the next level next year.”
While there are still some minor mysteries to solve on the path to greatness, several major points have been confirmed for Liz this week — including that of the horse’s stamina.
“He was so fresh today — he came out like, ‘eh, I didn’t do anything yesterday!’ He was wild this morning — he’s some machine. He had three more minutes in him when I finished yesterday; I just ran out of brakes, which is why we were slow, so I need to reassess that this winter. At the moment, he changes at every show, but it feels like we’re getting closer and closer to figuring each other out — and a great week like this puts me in a good, happy place to get on the road to Maryland 5*, too!”
Ros Canter’s Izilot DHI steps up to the plate at Boekelo. Photo by Tilly Berendt.
Coming to Boekelo is a big ask for a horse that’s naturally starstruck and spooky, but Ros Canter‘s Izilot DHI proved that quality wins out, and watching him gain in confidence and boldness through the week has been enormously exciting. He came to the event already a considerable success in his own right, with wins in CCI4*-S classes at Burgham and Bramham under his belt this season, but as a nine-year-old making his CCI4*-L debut, he was still unproven in many ways — and taking the pressure of expectation off was a huge part of Ros’s gameplan for the week.
“We’re over the moon with the way he’s coped,” says Ros. “Just to be here on the final day is a win in itself with Isaac, but he’s proved how much he’s grown up, and it makes it really exciting for next year. I didn’t really have any intentions about where we could be placed or anything like that — I mean, we all know he’s an out-and-out winner on his day, but this was really about trying to give him an experience that he enjoyed and building for his future. He’s had two big wins this year already, and hopefully this will build him up for another four long next year — and then we’ll see where we go after that!”
Ros and Isaac began the week in exceptional style, taking third place after the first phase on a score of 25, but a smattering of time penalties yesterday pushed them to ninth. Their clear inside the time today boosted them back up the order, and they took sixth place in the final standings.
“In the past, he’s been quite a flighty horse; if he’s been spooked or a bit nervous, like he was at Le Lion d’Angers, then he can go quite fast in the wrong direction,” says Ros. “But he was really good on cross-country. He was definitely a bit shell-shocked at first, and he didn’t really gallop towards the crowds for the first half of the course, so we struggled to stay on the minute markers right from the beginning because he was just drawing back a bit. But the thing I was most proud of was how honest he was at the jumps, even when there was so much going on, because that’s historically what he’s struggled with. He learned a lot from it — he’s tired, mentally, because he’s never experienced anything like this. It’s been a big week for him, and he’s ready for his holiday now!”
Boyd Martin and Fedarman B realise a dream for the Annie Goodwin Syndicate. Photo by Tilly Berendt.
No horse in the field has been as roundly cheered on as Boyd Martin‘s Fedarman B, who he rides for the Annie Goodwin Syndicate in honour of the eponymous late rider who produced the talented gelding to the upper levels. Each step of the way, he’s given Annie’s family and friends an enormous amount to celebrate as their horse makes his debut for Team USA: they sat in the top ten after the first day of dressage, and top fifteen after the second on their 29.8, then moved up to tenth after a clear round fifteen seconds inside the time. Today, though, was their star turn, as they delivered an impeccable clear inside the time to claim seventh place.
“We’re building a partnership, and we’re against some very, very good horses here, so to finish in the top group is something to be proud of — and I think that in our next international, we’ll be even stronger,” says Boyd sagely. “He’d be one of the best jumpers I’ve ever sat on; he’s got power, and scope, and bravery, and carefulness, and he’s just amazing quality. I’m very, very honoured and privileged to ride him and to be here in this company, and to finish on his dressage score gives us a lot to be proud of. It’s great having such a nice group around him, and Annie’s parents here, too.”
Boyd Martin and Fedarman B. Photo by Tilly Berendt.
Boyd, who was part of the silver medal-winning team at the World Championships in Pratoni last month, worked closely with Erik Duvander and Peter Wylde this week, alongside his teammates — and while he’s enjoying the afterglow of that historic success, the stalwart team member is always thinking of the marginal gains for his adopted nation.
“I think all the Americans had a great trip, and we’re still just a fraction off the best in the world, but we’re getting closer. We do still have to get a little bit better — I measure myself, personally, against the likes of Tim Price, and he’s part of that group that’s still just a notch better in their riding. I think that part B [of the US rebuilding project] is just getting ahold of the best horses in the world; I think there’s a handful of riders in America that are so close, and if we keep grinding away, I think we’ll get there.”
Susie Berry and the inexperienced, hugely exciting Clever Trick. Photo by Tilly Berendt.
When Ireland’s Susie Berry entered the ten-year-old Clever Trick for this event, it was with one goal in mind: give the inexperienced mare an education in the imitable atmosphere of Boekelo, and don’t worry a jot about the result along the way. But the Irish mare by Financial Reward has only gotten better and better throughout the week, capitalising upon a confident first-phase result of 31.8, which put her 28th, by adding nothing across the country yesterday and just 0.8 time penalties in today’s tough showjumping to take a final eighth place.
“She was kind of an unknown coming in,” says Susie, “but she was class in all three phases, to be honest. She’d be really green on the flat, but she was just as good in the ring as she is at home. She didn’t care about the atmosphere or anything; she just got the job done.”
The pair finished nine seconds inside the optimum time yesterday, making light work of a twisty track that flits through arguably the party of the year around the busy cross-country course.
“I knew she was fast and very good across the country, but it was the other two phases where she’d be pretty green,” says Susie, who took over the ride from fellow Irish rider Alex Donohoe over the winter. “This is actually my first four-star with her — we’ve done an Advanced and a CCI3*-L, but it was all very unknown. I’d hoped she’d perform, but I didn’t expect to be in the top ten, that’s for sure! It just felt like we were singing off the same hymn sheet this week. Going into the jumping I thought she’d be a bit tight, but she was so relaxed, and as long as I stayed relaxed with her, she felt so loose and chilled.”
Sandra Auffarth and the inexperienced but exciting Rosveel add another four-star placing to their 2022 resumé. Photo by Tilly Berendt.
2014 World Champion Sandra Auffarth dropped from sixth to ninth place after tipping a rail with the young Rosveel, but was delighted to add another placing to the Polish-bred talent’s resume after a third-place finish in the German National Championships CCI4*-S at Luhmühlen in June.
“He’s just nine years old, and every four-star he’s done he’s been clear in the cross-country — he’s so honest, and very special, I must say,” she says. “I’ve had him since a six-year-old, and he was always nice across the country, and really doing a good job with the dressage and jumping as well, so he’s really good and an exciting horse for the future.”
Stephane Landois and Chaman Dumontceau. Photo by Tilly Berendt.
France’s young talent shone through this week, with exciting performances across the country yesterday from a number of their riders under 30 — and it was the joint-fastest of the day, Stephane Landois and Chaman Dumontceau, who topped the bill and rounded out the top ten today. Looking no less fresh for his speedy round, which saw the pair finish 18 seconds inside the time, Chaman Dumontceau pinged his way to a one-rail round, moving up one space from eleventh as a result.
“It’s been a very good week – it’s just his second CCI4*-L, and he finished so well,” says Stephane of the ten-year-old gelding, with whom he won Lignières CCI4*-S a year ago. “He’s been very focused, so I’m so happy with him.”
Alyssa Phillips and Oskar finish off their first trip to Europe in fine style. Photo by Tilly Berendt.
Alyssa Phillips put a cap on her first experience competing in Europe when she posted one of the few clear rounds in this morning’s first showjumping session, boosting herself and the talented Oskar, previously produced by teammate Liz Halliday-Sharp, from 48th to 44th. The pair, who had been awarded a 20 yesterday for a circle between elements, impressed through the week on their team debut.
Janneke Boonzaaijer took the Dutch national title with her ebullient Bouncer, despite two rails and 3.2 time penalties that put her within a penalty of second-placed Beau Posthumus and Smokie. They finished 37th and 38th, respectively, in the overall leaderboard, while third-placed Adriaan Smeulders, making his return to Boekelo for the first time in two decades, finished 48th with Ekow.
The top ten after an exciting finale at the 2022 Military Boekelo CCI4*-L.
The British are back on top in the 2022 Nations Cup finale. Photo by Tilly Berendt.
The British team sealed the deal with a decisive win in the finale of the Nations Cup series, which they’d led from pillar to post with the team of Laura Collett and Dacapo, Ros Canter and Izilot DHI, Sarah Bullimore and Evita AP (20th after three rails), and Kirsty Chabert and Opposition Heraldik Girl (46th). They finished 6.2 penalties ahead of New Zealand, while France took the bronze position.
Germany, who finished fourth overall, took the 2022 series title in a three-way race between themselves, Italy (6th), and reigning champions Sweden (8th). Their team was largely made up of up-and-coming talent helmed by former World Champion Sandra Auffarth with Rosveel, Libussa Lübbeke and Darcy F (31st), 2019 Young Rider European Champions Emma Brüssau and Dark Desire GS (23rd), and Arne Bergendahl and Luthien 3 (33rd after cross-country but eliminated at the final horse inspection.)
The US, meanwhile, finished in fifth place after a good showing by the team was marred by a frustrating bit of bad luck saw James Alliston and Nemesis spun at the final horse inspection.
And so it ends, and we bid adieu to eventing’s greatest party, pack our passports, and head onwards to Maryland. Go Eventing.
The final team standings in Boekelo’s Nations Cup finale.
James Alliston and Nemesis bid adieu to Boekelo at the final inspection after delivering an excellent pathfinding round yesterday. Photo by Tilly Berendt.
Boekelo, eh? You think you’ve got it sussed, and then it surprises you all over again with — and you can take your pick, here — an inflatable stage in the main arena, a final fence that saw four fallers on cross-country, a middle-aged man determinedly wearing knee-high pink socks and using a duck ringtone loudly in the media centre, and an eye-wateringly dramatic final horse inspection.
Italy’s Umberto Riva and Falconn Sunheup Z. Photo by Tilly Berendt.
Despite the flat, relatively undemanding terrain and forgiving ground on yesterday’s course, a sum total of thirteen horses were sent to the holding box throughout the course of this morning’s trot-up, which was held before a ground jury of president Christina Klingspor, alongside Edith Schless-Störtenbecker and Merel Schurink. Seven of those were British, and included overnight leaders Laura Collett and Dacapo, as well as Laura’s second ride, Bling, who sits 47th overnight. They were both subsequently accepted on re-presentation, as were fellow countrymen Richard Coney and Poetry in Motion (38th), Izzy Taylor and Graf Cavalier (17th), Bella Innes-Kerr and Highway (46th), William Fox-Pitt and Moonlight Charmer (19th), and Ros Canter and Izilot DHI (9th).
Joining them in the hold box were delegates from a number of other countries, too. France’s Benjamin Massié and Edition Fonroy (16th) were held and subsequently accepted on re-presentation, as were Italy’s Tosca Brambilla and Legaland Mood Swing (55th) and Umberto Riva and Falconn Sunheup Z (25th), though the latter were asked to trot a second time in their re-presentation. 53 horses and riders will go through to showjumping, following the overnight withdrawal of Sweden’s Erika Sjöstrom and Mosstown Prince (57th) and France’s Sebastien Cavaillon and Quatchina Blue Z (37th) and Fabrice Saintemarie and Cronos de Pleysse (51st).
Ireland’s Camilla Spiers and BT Angelo. Photo by Tilly Berendt.
Three horses were sadly eliminated from the competition after re-presenting, and all three were part of Nations Cups teams. The USA’s James Alliston and Nemesis (30th), Ireland’s Camilla Spiers and BT Angelo (13th), and Germany’s Arne Bergendahl and Luthien 3 (33rd) will not continue on in the competition. That means that team USA drops from fourth to fifth going into the final phase, and Ireland drops from fifth to eighth, while Germany, whose riders all completed yesterday’s cross-country without jumping penalties, move up from sixth to fourth and remain at the forefront of the hunt for the series title, for which they’re competing against Italy — currently sixth — and Sweden, currently seventh.
Germany’s Arne Bergendahl and Luthien 3. Photo by Tilly Berendt.
The showjumping will begin from 11.30 a.m. local time (10.30 a.m. BST/5.30 a.m. EST), with the top twenty-five to follow from 14.30 local time (13.30 BST/8.30 a.m. EST). You can check out the times in full here, and as always, watch along here. We’ll be back with all the news and views you need to know — and in the meantime, Go Eventing!
Laura Collett and Dacapo maintain their first-phase lead, remaining on 21.9 after Boekelo’s cross-country day. Photo by Tilly Berendt.
Today’s cross-country at Military Boekelo CCIO4*-L could be fairly described as something of a day of two halves: on the one hand, despite riders’ assertions that it walked as more difficult than in previous years, we saw 59 of 74 starters complete — an 80% completion rate — and 44 of those jump clear, giving a clear rate of 59%. The optimum time of 10:10 proved not at all difficult to catch, too, with a whopping 19 competitors catching it.
But while it was, in many respects, the ‘softer’ Boekelo we’ve become used to, it still had its challenges — and most pertinent of those today was its final fence. A reasonably wide table-profiled fence, it walked as being wholly innocuous — but throughout the day, we saw three fallers here, including second-placed Giovanni Ugolotti and Swirly Temptress. Though each fall was different, as was each approach, each of the horses fell after leaving a left leg, and though officials tried to paint the top edges of the table white to make them more readable after the third fall, by the fourth, they opted simply to remove the jump altogether to keep horses and riders safe — though, as Technical Delegate Gillay Kyle was quick to remind people, that decision didn’t reinstate those four fallers.
One of those nineteen clears inside the time belonged to Laura Collett, who remains in the lead following the pivotal phase with Dacapo.
Longtime followers of Laura’s, though, will be just as familiar with the 13-year-oldDacapo for his misdemeanours as they are for his successes. He’s got plenty of major accolades under his belt, including second place at Aachen last year, but he’s also lost out on plenty more after silly runouts – an occasional habit that Laura hasn’t quite found her way to the bottom of.
“You never know what day he’s going to have, but he was amazing the whole way around,” she says. “You have absolutely no idea [when he’s going to be naughty] — it comes out of nowhere. He’s either going or he’s not, and there’s not a lot you can do about it! When he’s good he’s amazing, and he has his ears pricked and looks like he loves it, so you never quite know what’s going on in his head! When he’s like he was today, he’s mega — he never runs out.”
Dacapo certainly made Adrian Ditcham’s track look easy, coming in a hundredth of a second under the optimum time and never wavering in his approaches, even in the face of 60,000 enthusiastic partiers in close proximity to the tightly-roped track. But then, for all his quirks, Dacapo is a bit of a showman — and it’s that love of the spotlight that Laura hopes will buoy him to greatness tomorrow in the main arena where stablemate London 52 experienced the great turning point of his career.
“He’s a good jumper, but he can have a lazy rail here or there. He loves an atmosphere, though, so I’m hoping he rises to the occasion and tries a little bit harder,” says Laura. “Hopefully it’s his time to shine — he’s been in Dan’s shadow for long enough!”
Tim Price and Happy Boy. Photo by Tilly Berendt.
Three days into his tenure as the newly-minted World Number One, Tim Price puts himself well in contention for another international title, stepping up from equal fourth to overnight second with his 2019 Seven-Year-Old World Champion, Happy Boy. That movement came after the shock elimination of second-placed Giovanni Ugolotti, who fell at the final fence from Swirly Temptress, and the relocation within the top ten of third-placed Ros Canter and Izilot DHI, who added 4.4 time penalties to slip to ninth.
“He’s a great little horse,” says Tim, who came home three seconds inside the time with the ten-year-old Dutch-bred gelding. “He’s still getting used to this level; it’s only his second time around a course like this, but this is definitely the biggest challenge he’s seen in his career. I was really happy with him — he just kept coming and taking on all the questions.”
Though Happy Boy has previously experienced busy crowds at the Young Horse World Championships at Le Lion d’Angers, Boekelo’s atmosphere adds a whole new dimension — and something of an edge. When the long-term goal is to build a team horse for the future, though, that’s a valuable educational asset.
“I haven’t been here in about three years, and the course designer has changed in that time, so it’s pretty different. It’s a bit more gradual to get you into the technicality element of the course, and it feels a bit bigger, but the thing we get here every time is the crowds everywhere. For a young horse — and even for some of the more experienced four-star horses — they’re looking to the left and looking to the right, just clocking all these people leaning over the strings. It’s a brilliant feeling, but it’s a bit off-putting for the inexperienced ones. It’s what it’s all about, though, and it’s why we’re here — to get them used to this sort of thing.”
Tim’s round helps propel the New Zealand team into overnight second place in the Nations Cup, up one place from their post-dressage third — though still 11.1 penalties behind Great Britain, who continue to hold the lead after two phases. For the Kiwis, though, it’s all part of a recent, much-welcomed uptick in team fortunes.
“We’ve been a bit wavering over the last few years, but we got a great shot in the arm at the World Championships at Pratoni a couple of weeks ago,” says Tim. “It’s all about a bit of momentum, and then when you have someone else come into the frame that wasn’t there, you can pick them up and run with it, so it’s really exciting for the team.”
Tom McEwen pilots Nicola Wilson’s European Champion, JL Dublin, to a clear inside the time and overnight third. Photo by Tilly Berendt.
Another factor allowed Tim to move into second place, and after the brief frustration of Pratoni, at which he lost out on a tiebreak by being further under the optimum time than Boyd Martin, he’ll have breathed a sigh of relief to have been the victorious party this time. He and Tom McEwen both remain on 25.6 going into tomorrow’s showjumping, but as Tim was three seconds inside the time, it allowed him to inch ahead of now-third-placed Tom, who was four seconds inside the time on new ride JL Dublin.
While both rider and European Championship-winning horse is enormously experienced in his own right, this is their first significant competition in tandem: they’ve contested a couple of Intermediates, and used the CCI4*-S at Little Downham this month as a combined test, but have never yet run in an international. The partnership, helped along by the eleven-year-old gelding’s former rider Nicola Wilson, looked to be coming along in fine style, though.
Sarah Bullimore’s Evita AP is the best of the eight-year-olds in the field and will sit fourth overnight. Photo by Tilly Berendt.
The Boekelo field is always well-stocked with very young four-star horses, and the best of those today was Sarah Bullimore‘s eight-year-old Evita AP, who stepped up to the level just this season and was second in the prestigious eight- and nine-year-old CCI4*-S at Blenheim just last month. Though Sarah no longer has two horses in the top ten after an educational round with a 20 for the inexperienced Irish Trump, who slipped from seventh to 44th, she was delighted to secure fourth place overnight with the young mare, who also contributes to the British team effort. Their clear round, six seconds inside the time, boosts them from eighth after dressage.
“I had a fantastic ride – my mare’s only an eight-year-old, and she was fabulous,” says Sarah. “She’s just got a great, great brain on her, and she was out there ready for the next fence with her ears forward the whole way. She had a lovely time, and I’m chuffed to bits with her. She’ll have learnt an awful lot from coming here. They don’t see these sort of crowds anywhere else – it’s quite unique.”
Yasmin Ingham’s Rehy DJ embraces the atmosphere to romp home inside the time. Photo by Tilly Berendt.
Though her round won’t add to the British team effort after a last-minute switch-around on Wednesday, World Champion Yasmin Ingham is still well in contention for individual honours with Rehy DJ after a faultless clear 12 seconds inside the time boosted them from ninth to fifth and proved that, despite that Wednesday incident that saw the gelding sustain a superficial graze after being spooked by a water bowser, Rehy DJ is none the worse for wear.
Sandra Auffarth and Rosveel. Photo by Tilly Berendt.
Speaking of World Champions, the 2014 one put in a none too shabby show today herself. Germany’s Sandra Auffarth steps up from tenth to sixth with a faultless round aboard the nine-year-old Polish Sport Horse Rosveel, with whom she finished third in Luhmühlen’s CCI4*-S this summer. Just behind them, France’s Morgane Euriat and Baccarat d’Argonne jump from eleventh to seventh after a gutsy, attacking round that reminded spectators why exactly they were victorious in their first-ever CCI4*-L at Lignières last October, and just one second over the optimum in their second at Bramham under-25s this summer.
Liz Halliday-Sharp and Miks Master C add a smattering of time but remain in the top ten after a confident, exciting round from the inexperienced horse. Photo by Tilly Berendt.
Liz Halliday-Sharp is best of the US team, who slip from second to fourth overnight, despite dropping down two places to eighth after picking up 3.2 time penalties. But for Miks Master C‘s first time competing outside North America, and his first exposure to atmosphere, it’s an exciting milestone in the pair’s five month-long partnership.
“I was a little bit bummed to not make the time because he was quite strong, but honestly, he was fabulous,” says Liz, who pilots the gelding for stalwart owners Ocala Horse Properties and Debbie Palmer. “It was our first four-long together and he really showed he’s a world class horse. I’m excited about his future; I think it was a really good learning track for him. He’s a such a big, bold galloping horse and this is a very tight, twisting track.”
Though five months is barely any time at all in the grand scheme of an upper level partnership, Liz’s time with the gelding has been wholly focused on getting to know him and helping him to build his strength and balance – although sometimes, that strength can be a touch overenthusiastic.
“The biggest thing is he’s gotten so much stronger and fitter, and he’s suddenly realized he’s He-Man now, so he’s gotten to be a lot to hold on to — which is fine, I ride a lot of strong horses. He wants to do the job and he’s a big-striding horse. I was actually 30 seconds up on the time at the last water and I had to just thread the anchor back through the woods because I just didn’t have the control. But I do think he learned a lot; he went through the woods and was a bit strong and then he came back to me. I am quite disappointed about the time because I’m just really competitive, but I can’t fault the horse at all.”
“He’s been a bit of a different horse at every show I’ve done. This has kind of been a learning journey taking him here and finding a horse for the future. I think next year I’m going to have the horse I really know.”
Though Boekelo, with its twists and turns and smaller fences, wouldn’t be the obvious match for the big-striding, bold gelding, that’s partly why Liz wanted to aim him at the show.
“I think horses need to be able to do everything now,” she explains. “I’m trying to prime my horses up for all of the championships, and I think they need to do all the types of tracks. I think this could be a horse for me for the Olympics, but either way he’s proven to me today that he’s going to be a top five-star horse. And they need to prove they can twist and turn as well as gallop and jump.”
Ros Canter’s naturally spooky Izilot DHI steps up to the plate in a big way at Boekelo. Photo by Tilly Berendt.
Overnight third-placed Ros Canter moves down to ninth place after cross-country after adding 4.4 time penalties with Izilot DHI, who has been exceptional at CCI4*-S this season but hadn’t yet made the step up to this level.
“I’m absolutely delighted,” says Ros. “He’s still a very young horse; this is his first CCI4*-L, and he’s quite a sharp, spooky character, so it was a big occasion for him today. He won’t have seen anything like this, and he was a bit shy and nervous at the start, but so honest and genuine at the fences. I couldn’t be happier with him.”
Boyd Martin and Fedarman B. Photo by Tilly Berendt.
Boyd Martin rounds out the top ten with the Annie Goodwin Syndicate’s Fedarman B, who moved up from fifteenth place after going great guns around the course and showing how exceptionally his relatively new partnership with Boyd has come along. They finished fifteen seconds inside the time though, as Boyd explains, that wasn’t because he was pushing the horse for any kind of speed.
“When I came into it, I felt like I had him very, very fit because he was sort of the backup horse for Pratoni,” says Boyd. “So I had him galloping a lot early on in preparation and so he was ready for that. He showed me at the Tryon 4* that he could do the distance. This course here is a twisty course, and he’s got so much speed; he just gave me a great ride. I feel a bit embarrassed coming in fifteen seconds under the time! But he’s very light in the mouth and I was just seeing really good shots, and I don’t have to set him up too much.”
After Boyd jumped through the final water complex with the gelding, an enormous roar went up from the sidelines — such is the strength in depth of their support side this week as they ride in honour of the late Annie Goodwin, who passed away last year following a riding accident. For Boyd, it was great to give them something wonderful to cheer about.
“I’ve really only had him for a little over a year. He’s had one rider since he was three years old and that was Annie, so I couldn’t expect to hop on and have him go for me like he did for her. This time last year, we were eliminated at Morven Park, but we’ve gelled together — and it’s been great to have the Annie Goodwin Syndicate here cheering us on. Annie’s parents are here, so it’s just a brilliant atmosphere. Team USA has such great supporters today — and like Pratoni, it’s just an awesome group of riders. I think Liz, James, and Alyssa are some of the best riders America’s got, and it’s an honor and privilege to ride for the country.”
James Alliston and Nemesis make light work of pathfinder duties for Team USA. Photo by Tilly Berendt.
Though he was mounted on one of the greenest horses in the field in eight-year-old Nemesis, James Alliston made a fine job of taking team pathfinder duties in his Team USA debut, adding just 2 time penalties and bringing back valuable intel to his teammates. He was able to move up from 55th to 30th off the back of that great round.
“I just wanted to start out getting some good jumps, so I didn’t go blazingly fast,” says the West Coast rider, who rode for his native Great Britain until a few months ago. “He’s a fast horse, but at 4ABC, I kind of picked my way through probably in more strides that any other people. After that, he felt really good and confidence, and as I went, I sort of amped it up a little.”
Though they jumped most of the track brilliantly, they survived a near-miss moment at the last fence, which would go on to catch a number of riders and horses out throughout the day.
“It was maybe a little bit chancy coming home,” he says. “And next time, I’d start out a bit quicker!”
Alyssa Phillips and Oskar negotiate the tricky water complex. Photo by Tilly Berendt.
Team USA debutantes Alyssa Phillips and Oskar moved from 24th to 48th after picking up an unlucky run-out in the final water combination, plus a further 18.4 time faults — but the exciting gelding looked to gain in confidence on his way around the track, and will have learned plenty from the experience.
Janneke Boonzaaijer, 40th after cross-country after adding 14 time penalties with her CCI4*-L debutant Bouncer, takes the lead on the hunt for the Dutch National Championship after the retirement of first-phase leaders Tim Lips and Wicro Quibus.
“I am very happy with how it went,” says Janneke, who jumped through the tough main water complex with one stirrup, putting an enormous amount of faith in her inexperienced horse in doing so. “A lot of emotions; it was really insanely beautiful. In some places it all went just fine, like on the second water. It wasn’t easy; I really had to fight, but the result is great.”
Great Britain remains in the lead in the team competition, followed by New Zealand in second, French in third, and the US in fourth. Just three teams are in contention for the series title: Germany, who currently lead the standings, sit sixth, while Sweden is eighth of ten teams and Italy is seventh.
We’ll be back bright and early with all the news from the final horse inspection, set to take place from 9.30 a.m. local time/8.30 a.m. BST/3.30 a.m. EST. Until then: Go Eventing!
The top ten after cross-country at Military Boekelo.
The team standings at the close of the second phase in the Nations Cup competition.